Africa, a blessed continent has gone through episodes of sad experiences from slavery to colonization and today we are talking about neo-colonisation. Today as a multitude of African countries celebrate their independence from former colonisers for more than fifty years ago, the doubt about our sovereignty is still pending. Economic independence is certainly a long and tough battle against extractive institutions with their foundations laid during the colonisation periods; but it has to start somewhere, and monetary sovereignty is a start. In some African countries, more precisely, in most African francophone countries, it is discovered that the monetary link between these latter and their former coloniser still exists in the sense that the franc CFA, the common currency used in these countries is printed in France and this latter determines the functionalities of the currency going to the reserve of their central banks. A huge part of their external revenues are kept by the French treasury to guaranty the pegging of the franc CFA to the Euro. This is a sad reality in the 21st century. From a taboo subject, this topic has regained popularity these last days with calls from scholars and activists to break the franc CFA’s link. In between the for and against the franc CFA, we decided to carry a research study to analyse the fundamentals and the future of this situation.
Keywords: franc CFA; economic development; economic growth
ABBREVIATIONS
Franc CFA : Franc des Colonies Françaises d’Afrique
Franc of the French Colonies in Africa (in 1945)
Franc de la Communauté Française d’Afrique (In 1958)
Franc of the French African Community
Franc de la Communauté Financière d’Afrique (for UEMOA Countries)
Franc of the Financial African Community
Franc de la Coopération Financière en Afrique centrale (for CEMAC Countries)
Franc of the Financial Cooperation in Central Africa
ACFZ: African Countries of the Franc Zone
ACFZs: African Countries of the Franc Zones
UEMOA : Union Economique et Monétaire Ouest Africaine (in French)
WAEMU: West African Economic Monetary Union (in English)
CEMAC : Communauté Economique et Monétaire de l’Afrique Centrale
Economic and Monetary Community of Central African States
ECCAS: Economic Community of Central African States
WAMZ : West African Monetary Zone
BCEAO : Banque Centrale des Etats de l’Afrique de l’Ouest
Central Bank of West African States
BEAC : Banque des Etats de l’Afrique Centrale
Bank of Central African States
GDP: Gross Domestic Product
GNP: Gross National Product
ECOWAS: Economic Community of West African States
ECO: The propose name for the common currency the West African Monetary Zone plans to introduce in the framework of the Economic Community of West African States.
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Profession Distribution of Respondents…………………………………………………………80
Table 2: Distribution of area of study of Respondents……………………………………………………………………………81
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Profession Distribution of Respondents……………………………………………….80
Figure 2: Distribution of Area of expertise of Respondents………………………………..……81
Figure 3: Maintaining or not the franc CFA……………………………………………………..90
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DECLARATION…………………………………………………………………………………i
CERTIFICATION………………………………………………………………………………ii
DEDICATION………………………………………………………………………………….iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT……………………………………………………………………..iv
ABSTRACT……………………………………………………………………………………..vi
ABBREVIATIONS……………………………………………………………………………vii
LIST OF TABLES………………………………………………………………………………ix
LIST OF FIGURES…………………………………………………………………………….x
CHAPTER ONE………………………………………………………………………………………………………….15
INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………………………..15
1.1 Background to the Study……………………………………………………………….15
1.2 Statement of the Research Problem……………………………………………………17
1.3 Research Questions…………………………………………………………………….17
1.4 Objectives of the study…………………………………………………………………18
1.5 Research Proposition…………………………………………………………………..18
1.6 Significance of the Study………………………………………………………………18
1.7 Scope of the study………………………………………………………………………18
1.8 Limitation of the Study…………………………………………………………………19
1.9 Organization of the Study………………………………………………………………19
References………………………………………………………………………………….21
CHAPTER TWO………………………………………………………………………………27
LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK……………………..70
2.1. Introduction…………………………………………………………………………..,.73
2.2. Conceptual Clarification……………………………………………………………….73
2.1.1. History of the Franc CFA……………………………………………………………29
2.1.2. Functioning of the Franc CFA………………………………………………………29
2.1.3. The concept of Economic Development…………………………………………….30
2.1.4 Measuring Economic Development…………………………………………………35
2.1.5 The Link between Political Institutions and Economic Institutions…………………36
2.1.5.1 The Different types of Political Institutions and Economic Institutions……………36
2.1.5.2 The nexus between Political Institutions and Economic Institutions……………….38
2.1.5.3 Extractive institutions and access to markets……………………………………….39
2.1.5.4 The Role of Rent Extraction…………………………………………………………41
2.1.5.5 The impact of extractive institutions on economic growth and development………42
2.3. Theoretical Framework…………………………………………………………………44
2.3.1. Dependency development theory…………………………………………………….45
2.3.2. Foundations and Main Principles of the Dependency Theory………………………….45
2.3.3. Application of the dependency theory to the study 49
2.3.4. Major Critiques of the Dependency Theory 50
3.2.1. Research Design 61
3.2.2. Population of the study 62
3.2.3. Sample Size 62
3.2.4. Instruments of Data Collection 62
3.2.5. Validity and Reliability of Instrument 62
3.2.6. Method of Data Analysis. 63
3.2.7. The Study Issues 63
DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS. 78
4.2 Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ Bio-data. 78
4.2.1 Analysis of Respondents by Profession. 78
4.2.2 Analysis of Respondents by Area of study. 78
4.3.1. Analysis of Proposition 1. 79
4.3.2. Analysis of Proposition 2. 92
4.3.3. Analysis of Proposition 3. 96
4.4. Summary of Findings. 100
SUMMARY, RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS. 110
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
- Background to the Study
At the eve of the sixtieth independence of most African states, one question has always resonated in the mind of most Africans: Are we really independent? ‘’Independence is only the prelude to a new and more involved struggle for the right to conduct our own economic and social affairs.’’ (Nkrumah, 1963, as cited in Akhalbey, 2019). Independence stipulates that one is able to stand on his own and do far better than when he was subjected. In the case of some African countries, stagnation is observed after independence rather than prosperity. According to Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson, two renowned economists specialized in development studies; various countries that underwent colonization are poor today because of extractive institutions that were put in place during colonization and still subsist after independence. Acemoglu and Robinson (2012) state that the extractive structures that underpinned these nations’ deprivation were introduced or at least further strengthened, by the very same mechanism that fuelled European development, fuelled European growth: European commercial and colonial expansion.
Looking back to the days of colonization, these economists explained how colonization disrupted the economic development of its victim countries giving the example of some regions in South Asia; Acemoglu and Robinson (2012) state that the Dutch spread the technique they consummated in the Moluccas to the whole area, with significant ramifications for the monetary and political establishments of the remainder of Southeast Asia. The long business extension of a few states in the territory that had begun in the fourteenth century went into invert. Indeed, even the commonwealths which were not legitimately colonized and squashed by the Dutch East India Company turned internal and relinquished exchange. The early monetary and political change in Southeast Asia was ended in its tracks. As high minded circles make comprehensive foundations endure, horrendous circles make amazing powers toward the steadiness of extractive organizations. History is not fate and awful circles are not solid. Be that as it may, they are versatile. They make an incredible procedure of negative input, with extractive political organizations manufacturing extractive monetary foundations, which thusly make the reason for the diligence of extractive political establishments. Various nations succeeded in breaking out from extractive institutions and rebuilt their economies. Some, just like francophone countries in Africa see their economies being held down by some extractive economic institutions. Countries flop today in light of the fact that their extractive financial establishments do not make the motivators required for individuals to spare, contribute and advance. Extractive political organizations bolster these monetary establishments by solidifying the intensity of the individuals who profit by the extraction. Ndongo Samba Sylla (2016) states that if Africa has emerged from certain forms of colonialism, there are others in which it is still mired just over fifty years after independence. In the case of the franc zone countries, it is for example their monetary relations with France and the euro zone.
The economies of the Francophone African countries using the franc CFA depend on the French treasury. The currency used by these countries are printed in France and regulated by the French treasury. Although the Franc Zone entity has been formally recognized internationally since 1939 with the establishment of foreign exchange policy common to all French territories, it is only from 1945 that one will attend a real organization of it. On December 26, 1945, a communiqué from the French Minister of Finance officially gave birth to it.
The franc CFA was meant for the “Franc of the French Colonies in Africa’’ before becoming later in 1958, the” Franc of French African Community “. After the independence of the French colonies of Africa, it became the “Franc of the Financial Community of Africa” and the “Franc of the Financial Cooperation in Central Africa “on the territory of Central Africa. It is issued by two institutes: the Central Bank of West African States (BCEAO) and the Bank of Central African States (BEAC). The Franc CFA is75 years of existence in 2020.
Currently, the monetary system of the Franc zone, which covers France and fifteen African States (the West African Economic and Monetary Union is constituted of eight member states) (UEMOA), six for the Economic and Monetary Community of Central African States (CEMAC) and the Comoros is highly controversial. The devaluation of the franc CFA in 1994 marked an important episode in the history of the Franc zone, which combined with a transition to economic and complementary unions and monetary unions. The purpose of setting up these monetary unions was to implement customs union between the member countries and a common market and certain common policies at the general level. With the attachment of the Franc to the Euro, in 1998, agreements between the countries of the Franc zone and the European Union were signed to maintain the fixed parity between the franc CFA and the Euro, while respecting the agreements linking France and the countries of the Franc zone. The debate on the desirability for the countries whether to leave the Franc zone or not has been resurfacing in recent years, draining a lot of passion and leading almost to a frontal opposition between supporters of the franc CFA and its opponents.
Strict monetary discipline imposed to the two central banks, through the transaction account, is perceived as being to reduce the amount of funding available to national economies in order to support investments and growth. Some associate the Franc zone with low access to bank credit, the perceived high level of debit interest rates and the predominance of short-term credits, including consumer credit, over longer term loans to finance the investment.
Another argument on which the supporters of the exit of the Franc zone rely is the overvaluation of the currency resulting from the staking of the franc CFA in hard currencies (French Franc, Euro).
Then again, supporters of the state of affairs see the Franc zone as a significant local incorporation device that ought to go past the UEMOA space or CEMAC to cover separately that of the Economic Community of West Africa States (ECOWAS) or the Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS). Mbaye, A. A. and Mballa, C. (2019) state the current debate on the Franc zone puts into perspective some files and projects unfinished in West and Central Africa. As much as it is difficult to speak of structural transformation for most Central African countries, as much as to discuss the experience of setting up the single currency of ECOWAS. Since its creation in 1975, this institution has achieved important milestones in the materialization of economic integration. Heads of State and Government launched in May 1983 in Conakry, Guinea, the idea of creating a single currency and decided to devote all necessary attention as an essential step in integration. So, a Monetary Cooperation Program was set up in July 1987 with the aim that this currency would be managed by a common Central Bank. However, ECOWAS still has difficulties in achieving integration despite the adoption, almost 30 years ago, of the Cooperation Program and Monetary Fund and despite an obvious desire to speed up the creation of the single currency regularly renewed by the political leaders of the region.
To examine the issues raised by the Franc zone, the objective is to relay questions, including those concerning the effectiveness of monetary policy and the integration of the economies it underpins. It is also to subject the tool area ‘’Franc CFA’’ to a Relevance Test, in the face of the real prospects of development of the countries concerned.
- Statement of the Research problem
Most Francophone African countries have adopted the franc CFA since 1945. Since then monetary policies have been developed to ensure the sustainability of the franc Zone. The pegging of the franc CFA from the French Franc (FF) to the Euro and the maintaining of a fixed parity between both currencies; the devaluation of the franc CFA in 1994 and the creation of the West African Economic Monetary Union (WAEMU) to ensure a common monetary policy and facilitate trade among Franc zone countries in West Africa.
There have been demands for an end of the franc CFA by some scholars who have argued that its monetary policies affect Franc zone countries; because fixed parity policy takes precedence over any internal monetary objective; they do not facilitate economic development; there is a weak intra-Community trade in the CFA zones and the persistence of these economies in a position of primary integration into international trade. Despite the low wages and the standard of living of the African Countries of the Franc Zones populations, they do not enjoy good export price competitiveness because of the pegging of the CFA to a strong currency.
Some other scholars favor the continuous existence of the franc CFA which is considered as the motor of regional economic integration in Franc zones and enables the economic stability of its member countries.
This study would use Togo as a case study. It will evaluate the effects of the franc CFA on the economic development in that country.
1.3 Research questions
The study has the following research questions:
- How has the franc CFA affected the economic development of Togo?
- In which ways can Togo achieve an economic development on its own?
- What will be the effects of opting out of the Franc zone?
1.4 Objectives of the study
The general objective of the study is to expose the impacts of the franc CFA on the economies of the African Countries in the Franc Zones, especially in Togo.
The specific objectives are:
- To investigate the role of the franc CFA in favoring economic freedom in Togo.
- To buttress the need to get rid of the franc CFA to attain an economic development.
- To navigate possible alternatives to the franc CFA.
1.5 Research proposition
These are propositions guiding the research written in all form:
- The franc CFA has no significant impact on the economic development of Togo.
- Togo’s economic development lies out of the franc zone.
- There are possible alternatives to the franc CFA.
- Significance of the study
This study is focused on the economic development and monetary policies in franc zone countries with Togo as a case study. It shall elaborate on the various debates on the franc CFA. It shall also examine the necessity of an economic sovereignty. This research is adding to knowledge by enlightening on the impact of the franc CFA on former French colonies and on the parameters of economic development. The study will be of great relevance for researchers, policy-makers and analysts interested in economic development of African countries and the debate on the franc CFA.
1.7 Scope of the study
This study shall examine the political and economic undertone of the franc CFA and its impacts on the economies of African Countries of the Franc Zone with Togo as a case study. The period covered will be 2000-2020.
- Limitation of the study
During this study, some challenges were faced among which some unmanageable delays by interviewers in submitting their responses in due time.
1.9 Organization of the study
This investigation involves five sections. Part One presents this examination study. It incorporates the foundation to the investigation, explanation of the issue, research questions, research targets, and exploration speculations, centrality of the examination, extent of the investigation, constraints of the investigation and association of study.
Part two comprises of the Literature Review and Theoretical Framework which investigates the current writing around there of study or examination. It additionally basically investigates existing writing on this theme and examines the hypothetical structure. The writing survey utilized in the examination, especially in this part will incorporate articles, diaries and online materials.
Chapter Three consists of research methodology and the historical background of the Franc zone. This research makes use of the qualitative method which aims at getting a detailed description of observation, hence providing valuable and insightful data. In the same vein, this research work also engages primary sources of data, including in-depth interview, just as auxiliary wellsprings of information, which consist of journal reviews and newspaper articles.
Section Four is the information introduction and investigation which includes data gathered through the use of primary and secondary sources. This chapter evaluates the effects of the Franc CFA on Togo’s economy. It would include the summary and discussion of findings.
Chapter five contains the summary, proposes the recommendations and conclusion to the study as well as proffer suggestions for further studies.
References
Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. (2012). Why nations fail. New York: Crown.
Agboli, C. (2015). Pourquoi un débat scientifique sur le franc CFA est-il tabou? .Retrieved from www.lemonde.fr: http://www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2015/06/04/pourquoi-un-debat-scientifique-sur-le-franc-cfa-est-iltabou_4647272_3212.html#pJijBxjy7kOIwFUH.99
Aghion, P., Cohen, E., & Pisani-Ferry, J. (2006). Politique économique et croissance en Europe. Conseil d’analyse économique. Paris: La Documentation francaise.
Akhalbey, F. (2019). Kwame Nkrumah’s iconic 1963 speech on African unity.(History, Ed.) Retrieved from www.face2faceafrica.com: https://face2faceafrica.com/article/read-kwame-nkrumahs-iconic-1963-speech-on-african-unity
Amah, J. (2020, March 15). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo. (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Amin, S., & Aloysius, A. (2000). Long Term Growth in the CFA franc Zone Countries . World Institute for Development Economics Research .
Banque de France. (2013). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015 ). Rapport annuel de la zone franc, Annex 1 and 2. Eurosystème .
BCEAO. (2014). Rapport annuel de la Commission Bancaire. Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.
BEAC . (2007). Convention de Compte d’Opérations de la Banque des Etats d’Afrique Centrale .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politiqque monétaire .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politique monétaire .
Bearce, D. H. (2010). Monetary divergence : Domestic policy autonomy in the Post-Bretton Woods Era . Michigan Studies in International Political Autonomy .
Bebchuk, L., & Fried, J. (2004). The managerial power perspective. In L. Bebchuk, & J. Fried, Pay without performance : the unfulfilled promise of executive compensation . Cambridge: Havard University Press .
Broz, J. L., & Jeffry, A. F. (2001). The Political Economy of International Monetary Relations. Annual Review Political Science , 317-343.
Bryman, A. (2012). Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
Burda, M., & Wyplosz, C. (2013). Macroeconomics : a European text. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Calvo, G., & Coricelli, F. (1993). Output collapse in Eastern Europe : the role of credit. IMF Staff Papers, 40 (1), 32-52.
Carlos, L. (2016, October 3). Entretien de Carlos Lopes sur RFI.Retrieved from http://www.rfi.fr: http://www.rfi.fr/emission/20161003-afrique-carloslopes-onu-franc-cfa-economie-monnaies-zone-franc-royaume-uni-ue
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique, 66, 42-55.
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique (66), 42-55.
Central Intelligence Agency. (1994). Africa Review, Special Issue : Impact of CFA Devaluation in Francophone Africa. Directorate of Intelligence .
Cessou, S. (2015). Un ministre a-t-il le droit de dire tout le mal qu’il pense du franc CFA?Retrieved from http://rue89.nouvelobs.com: http://rue89.nouvelobs.com/blog/ruesdafriques/2015/05/14/un-ministre-t-il-le-droit-de-dire-tout-le-mal-quil-pense-du-franc-cfa-234557
Claude, K. T. (2020, March 19). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Clément, J. (1996). Aftermath of the CFA Franc Devaluation . The International Monetary .
Combey, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2010). Les effets non linéaires de l’infliation sur la croissance dans l’UEMOA. Communication au Symposium de l’Institut monétaire de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (IMAO).Accra.
Cooper, F. (2002). Africa since 1940 : The Past of the Present. Cambridge : Cambrigde University Press.
Cooper, F. (2015). L’Afrique dans le monde : Capitalisme, empire, Etat-nation.Paris: Payot.
Couharde, C., Coulibaly, I., & Damette, O. (2011). Misalignments and dynamics of real exchange rates in the CFA franc zone. EconomiX, Working Papers.
Daly, J. (2014). Counterterrorism or Neo-Colonialism? The French Army in Africa. Retrieved from jamestown.org: https://jamestown.org/program/counterterrorism-or-neo-colonialism-the-french-army-in-africa/
Dembélé, D. M. (2011). Table ronde sur le Franc CFA : Que faire de la zone économique et monétaire du franc CFA, la Zone Franc : Instrument de controle et frein au développement des économies Africaines . SciencePo Paris .
Dieng, C. (2015). Idriss Deby appelle les pays africains à se débarrasser du Franc CFA.Retrieved from Afrik.com: http://www.afrik.com/idriss-deby-appelle-les-pays-africains-a-se-debarrasser-du-franccfa#YJ08iWjLKAEZcdJu.99
Folarin, S. (2020, February 26). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Frank, A. G. (1981). Reflections on the World Economics Crisis. Fund .
Frank, A. G. (1966). The Developement of Underdevelopment. London: Arnold .
Frey, L., Botan, C., & Kreps, G. (1999). Investigating communication : An introduction to research methods. Boston & Bacon: Allyn & Bacon.
George, A. L., & Bennett, A. (2005). Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. MIT Press .
Gill, S. (1993). Gramsci, Historical Materialism and Inteernational Relations . Cambrigde University Press .
Graeber, D. (2013). Dette, 5000 ans d’histoire. Paris: Les Liens qui libèrent.
Griffin, C. (2007). French Military Interventions in Africa : Realism vs. Ideology in French Defense Policy and Grand Strategy . International Studies Association .
Gulde, A.-M. (2008). The CFA Franc Zone : Common Currency, Uncommon Challenges. International Monetary Fund Books .
Hallet, M. (n.d.). The role of the euro in Sub-Saharan Africa and in the CFA franc zone. Economic and Financial Affairs, European Commission, Economic , 347.
Ibid. (2000). L’analyse des deux vagues de politiques monétaires restrictives en Russie de 1993 à 1999.
Ibrahima Jr, D. (2020, February 1). A Dakar, Kako Nubukpo appelle l’Afrique à rompre avec la “croissance sans développement”.Retrieved from https://www.financialafrik.com: https://www.financialafrik.com/2020/02/01/a-dakar-kako-nubukpo-appelle-lafrique-a-rompre-avec-la-croissance-sans-developpement/
Kaldor, M. (2007). Oil and Conflict. London: Pluto Press.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
La France et l’outre-mer : un siècle de relations monétaires et financières. (1996). Actes du colloque tenu à Bercy (p. 695). Bercy: Comité pour l’histoire économique et financière de la France.
Lelart, M. (2003). L’Union monétaire en Afrique de l’Ouest. L’Economie politique , 19 (3), 106-112.
Massimo, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2020, Mars). Una nuova moneta per gli Stati dell’Ovest. Le condizioni teoriche e politiche della sua fattibilita. Moneta e Credito .
Mbaye, A. A., & Mballa, C. (2019). La zone Franc d’hier à aujourd’ui. Interventions économques : Papers i,n Political economy .
Mborg, R. (2015). Le franc CFA freine le développement de l’Afriqque. Le Monde .
McMichael, P. (2011). Development and Social Change : A Global Perspective . SAGE Publications .
Messanh, N. L. (2017, March 13). Le Togolais Kako Nubukpo primé pour son ouvrage « L’envol de l’Epervier : le défi de l’émergence togolaise ».Retrieved August 4, 2020, from financialafrik: https://www.financialafrik.com/2017/03/13/le-togolais-kako-nubukpo-prime-pour-son-ouvrage-lenvol-de-lepervier-le-defi-de-lemergence-togolaise/
Minart, G. (2016). Jaquier Rueff : Un liberal francais.Paris: Odile Jacob.
Mundell, R. (1961). A theory of optimum currency areas. American Economic Review (4).
Ndongo, S. S. (2017, July 12). Firoz Lalji Centre for Africa. Retrieved July 27, 2020, from https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/africaatlse/2017/07/12/the-cfa-franc-french-monetary-imperialism-in-africa/
Nkrumah, K. (1965). Neo-Colonialism, the Last Stage of imperialism.
Nubukpo, K. (2020, January 21). Eco et franc CFA : quatre mariages et un enterrement.Retrieved January 29, 2020, from www.jeuneafrique.com: https://www.jeuneafrique.com/884260/economie/tribune-eco-et-franc-cfa-quatre-mariages-et-un-enterrement/
Nubukpo, K. (2016). Le Franc CFA et le financement de l’émergence en zone franc . 123-133.
Nubukpo, K. (2011). L’improvisation économique en Afrique de l’Ouest – Du Cotton au Francc CFA. Paris : Khartala.
Nubukpo, K. (2019). L’Urgence africaine : Changeons le modèle de croissance ! Paris: Odile Jacob.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : La gestion du franc CFA par la BCEAO. Politique africaine, 105, 70-82.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : la gestion du franc CFA par la BECEAO. Politique africaine (105), 70-82.
Nubukpo, K., & Deh, C. P. (2016). L’envol de l’épervier : le défi de l’émergence Togolaise. Lomé: Graines de Pensées.
Nubukpo, K., Belinga, M., & Dembélé, D. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la sevitude monétaire. Paris, France: La dispute.
Nubupko, K., Belinga, M. Z., Tinel, B., & Dembélé, D. M. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la servitude monétaire : A qui profite le franc CFA ?Paris: La Dispute.
Oatley, T., & Kindred, W. (2014). Handbook of the international political economy of monetary relations. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
O’Brien, R., & Williams, M. (2013). Global political economy. Palgrave Macmillan.
Ould-Ahmed, P. (1999). Politiques monétaires, comportements bancaires et crises de financement en Russie : les vicissitudes des années 1990. Revue d’études comparatives Est-Ouest,, 30 (2-3), 89-121.
Pape, L. D. (1998). L’impact des taux directeurs de la BCEAO sur les taux débiteurs des banques . Notes d’Information et Statistiques , 483-484.
Pigeaud, F. (2016). Une monnaie nocive pour les Etats africains. Médiapart .
Polzer, T. (2001). Corruption : Deconstructing the World Bank Discourse. Development Studies Institute, London School of Economics, Working Paper Series, 1470 (2320).
Profant, T. (2010). French Geopolitics in Africa : From Neo-colonialism to Identity. Perspectives, 18 (1).
Saint-Légier, R. (1956). La zone franc, mécanismes, problèmes internationaux. Annuaire francaise de droit international, 2 (1956), 260-27.
Shatz, H. J., & Tarr, D. (2000). Exchange Rate Overvaluation and Trade Protection : Lessons from Experience . The World Bank .
Shillington, K. (2005). History of Africa. Macmillian Publishers Limited.
Smith, N. (2013). What is ”neoclassical” economics?
Strange, S. (1988). States and markets. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Todaro, M., & Smith, S. (2015). Economic development. Harlow: Pearson.
Trésor Direction Générale. (2013). 40 ans d’histoire de la Zone franc – Principes et modalités de fonctionnement de la coopération monétaire. Paris: Ministère de l’économie, République Francaise .
UEMOA. (1973). Traité du 14 novembre 1973 constituant l’Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.Préambule.
United Nations Development Programme. (1997). Human Development Report . Oxford University Press.
United Nations. (2006). Human Development Report. Beyond scarcity: Power, poverty and the global water crisis. United Nations Development Programme. Palgrave Macmillan.
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Credit policy, inflation and growth in a financially repressed economy. Journal of Development Economics, (13).
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Interest rate management in LDC. Journal of Monetary Economics, 12 (12).
World Bank. (2017). GDP per capita growth (annual%). The World Bank Group.
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
2.1 Introduction
This chapter is divided into two segments. The first section comprises of the conceptual clarification and the second section of this chapter focuses on the theoretical framework for the study.
2.2 Conceptual Clarification
This section attempts in this review to conceptualise the central themes. This conceptualisation will give this study clarification. Identifying these concepts act as the basis for other study pieces, and removing conceptual errors.
2.2.1 History of the Franc CFA
The franc CFA was at first made in 1939, not long before World War II, yet just truly appeared on December 26, 1945, after the gathering in Bretton Woods. Since France consented to the Bretton Woods Arrangement and in the long run downgraded and listed the French franc to the US dollar, France chose to make new monetary standards in its abroad territories. The objective was to encourage sends out from the settlements to France, while simultaneously re-establishing France’s fiscal authority over these regions, which had been separated from the metropolis during the contention (Nubukpo et al, 2016, p.86).
In any case, during the Second World War, French states encountered a cash rarefaction, and from time to time expected to rely upon “improvised” close by money related guidelines pegged to financial structures other than the French franc, for instance, the US dollar. The franc CFA by then transformed into the ‘ Franc of the French African Community ‘ (FCFA) in 1958, after General de Gaulle introduced the possibility of ‘ organize ‘ into the West and Central African repayments.
In 1960, Guinea left the franc zone, and set up its own cash and national bank. The new French franc of December 1958 had a fixed equality of one French franc (FF) for 50 FCFA (Ibid, p.89). This equality would not change for the following 36 years, until the degrading of the franc was forced by France, on twelfth January 1994.
Past this sequential fight, the creativity and the peculiarity of the franc zone are because of its working. Not at all like the current money board model in the British Empire, is not the issue of unfamiliar cash connected to the load of unfamiliar trade saves accessible. At the end of the day, the issue of the franc CFA should be possible using a loan, on account of the assurance contributed by the French Treasury to the boundless convertibility of the franc CFA and the fixed rate swapping scale with the franc, at that point with the euro. The partner of this assurance is the installment by the franc zone states, by means of their national banks, of part of their unfamiliar money saves on a record opened for the sake of the French Treasury. It’s this system solitary, called “working record”, which is today collectively tested brought about by pundits of the franc zone and by the supporters of its change. (Duchaussoy, 2017, p.3)
In the second 50% of the 1980s, a sharp fall in cocoa, espresso, cotton and oil costs on worldwide markets battered the CFA-zone economies. All the while, the energy about the French franc against other significant monetary forms made the zone’s fares less serious (Ibid, p.85). This one-two punch, joined with rising wages and installment unpaid debts, brought about falling venture and capital flight. The cheapening of 1994 end up being a genuine stun for the economies of the zone. The cash lost a large portion of its incentive in one night as one French franc, already worth 50 FCFA, became worth 100 FCFA (Ibid, p.100).
It denoted a significant scene throughout the entire existence of the Franc zone, which joined with a progress to financial, reciprocal associations and fiscal associations. The reason for setting up these money related associations was to place of a traditions joining between part nations and of a typical market and certain regular strategies at general level. With the pegging of the Franc to the Euro, in 1998 understandings between the nations of the Franc zone and the European Union were marked to keep up the fixed equality between the franc CFA and the Euro, while regarding the understandings connecting France and the nations of the Franc zone (Mbaye et al, 2019, p. 2). Starting at 2015, the cash is utilized by 150 million individuals across 14 nations. The discussion on the open door for nations Africans whether to leave the Franc zone has remerged lately depleting a great deal of enthusiasm and practically prompting a frontal restriction between supporters of the franc CFA and its adversaries. (Mbaye et al, 2019, p.2-3).
2.2.2 Functioning of the Franc CFA
The current segment contains a non-thorough rundown of the primary guidelines and standards of the franc CFA. The franc CFA zone depends on four key standards:
A swelling objective is likewise forced upon the CFA nations: the UEMOA (the West African zone of the franc CFA) has a 2 % expansion target while the CEMAC (the Central zone) has a 3% limit on swelling. Also, France forces a 20% least pace of inclusion of the financial base so as to ensure the peg. This pace of inclusion compares to the measure of sight liabilities as unfamiliar trade saves that a national bank holds according to its fiscal base (Gulde, 2008, p.7). As will be clarified in detail in another segment, this fundamentally restricts the entrance to credit for financial operators, in this way obstructing monetary development and advancement.
2.2.3 The concept of Economic Development
The soonest idea of advancement was deciphered regarding development of yield after some time and later as far according to capita yield. The terms development and advancement were utilized conversely. During 1950 and 1960s many creating nations understood their monetary development targets yet way of life of the individuals didn’t change. Truth be told presence of mass destitution, absence of education and sick wellbeing kept on plaguing the creating nations. This suggested there was some kind of problem with this meaning of monetary turn of events. The vast majority of the financial specialists clamoured for deposing of GNP and characterize advancement as far as evacuation of destitution, lack of education, ailment and changes in the arrangement of information and yield, increment in per capita yield of material merchandise. Increment in yield of merchandise and ventures and in salary doesn’t suggest an improvement in the way of life of the individuals since GDP is a limited pointer of monetary advancement that does exclude non-financial markers, for example, recreation time, access to wellbeing, training, condition, opportunity or social equity (George and Bennett, 2005, p.38).
Financial improvement is accordingly a multivariate idea; consequently there is no single acceptable meaning of it. Monetary advancement is where low salary national economies are changed into present day modern economies. It includes subjective and quantitative upgrades in a nation’s economy. Political and social changes are additionally remembered for the idea of financial improvement notwithstanding monetary changes.
Truly, monetary improvement can be characterized as “entry from lower to higher stage which suggests change”. (Kindleberger and Herrick, 1958 referred to in Burda and Wyplosz, 2013) call attention to: “Monetary advancement is commonly characterized to remember enhancements for material government assistance particularly for people with the least livelihoods, the destruction of mass neediness with its associates of absence of education, illness and early demise, changes in the synthesis of information sources and yield that by and large remember shifts for the basic structure of creation away from farming towards mechanical exercises, the association of the economy so that beneficial business is general among working age populace as opposed to the circumstance of an advantaged minority, and the correspondingly more prominent cooperation of wide based gatherings in settling on choice about the course, financial and something else, in which they should move their government assistance”. Kindleberger while making a qualification between monetary development and financial improvement contends that: “Financial advancement infers both more yield and changes in the specialized and institutional course of action by which it is created and conveyed”. Monetary advancement in the old style time meant:”an increment in unquestionably the size of yearly creation paying little mind to the size of the populace, or an expansion in the economy’s genuine pay over a significant stretch of time”.
Subsequently in the expressions of (Meier, 1964 refered to in Todaro and Stephen, 2012), “monetary improvement is a procedure whereby an economy’s genuine national pay increments over an extensive stretch of time”. This definition neglects to consider the adjustments in the development of populace. In the event that an ascent in genuine pay is joined by quicker development in populace there will be no monetary turn of events however hindrance. Along these lines, a few market analysts characterize financial advancement regarding an expansion in per capita pay. Drewnewski (1966) characterizes advancement regarding financial and social government assistance, “In the way of life of individuals monetary improvement is steady and it includes expanded per capita salary and production of new open doors in training, human services, business segments. Improvement is of restricted centrality on the off chance that it doesn’t prompt monetary government assistance. Monetary improvement suggests expanded per capita salary and diminished pay disparities and fulfillment of the individuals all in all”.
In 1970’s redistribution from development turned into a typical trademark. Dudley Seers (1972) brought up the fundamental issue about the importance of advancement concisely when he stated inquiries concerning a nation’s turn of events, for example, “what has been going on to neediness? What has been going on to joblessness? What has been going on to disparity? In the event that each of the three of these have declined from significant levels, at that point past this comprises time of advancement for the nation concerned. In the event that a couple of these focal issues have been deteriorating, particularly if every one of the three have it is abnormal to call the outcome improvement regardless of whether per capita pay multiplied”.
McGranahan (1972) presents social elements as a significant marvel during the time spent financial turn of events. As indicated by McGranahan, “improvement hypothesis is tremendously engrossed with the pace of social components as sources of info or essentials for monetary development. It is broadly accepted that disregard of these variables has been an explanation behind frustrating pace of monetary development. Simultaneously it is apparent that there is no basic general law that can be expressed with respect to the monetary effect of instruction, wellbeing, lodging and other social segments”.
Financial advancement incorporates monetary development estimated as far as GDP and its distributional measurements. In regard of this a few financial specialists incorporate job of decreasing neediness, arrangement of improving essential needs, merchandise and enterprises and diminished disparities in pay dispersion in the meaning of monetary advancement which can be accomplished by expanding the pace of creation and business. In this way, the development of profitable business is another measurement which is remembered for the meaning of monetary turn of events.
Vocalist and Ansari (1977) characterize improvement regarding abatement of neediness “By financial advancement is implied not just an expansion in the GNP of a nation yet rather a lessening in destitution at an individual level. Most likely the best markers of neediness are low food utilization and higher joblessness. In the event that these issues are viably managed development of GNP and with a sensibly impartial salary appropriation at that point and at exactly that point can authentic financial improvement be talked of”’.
In 1980 The World Bank sketched out the difficulties of advancement as monetary improvement which can be accomplished by expanding the pace of creation and work. Therefore, the development of profitable work is another measurement which is remembered for the meaning of financial turn of events.
In 1980 The World Bank sketched out the difficulties of advancement as monetary development, and joined the perspectives on onlookers taking a more extensive viewpoint when in its 1991 World Development Report, it affirmed: “The test of improvement is to improve personal satisfaction. Particularly on the planet’s helpless nations, a superior personal satisfaction by and large calls for higher wages however it includes substantially more. It envelops as finishes in themselves better training, better quality of wellbeing and sustenance, less neediness, a more clear condition, greater balance of chance, more prominent individual opportunity, and a more extravagant social life”.
In 1990’s financial experts characterized advancement regarding human government assistance, better training, low joblessness, low hunger, sickness, low destitution, greater correspondence and so forth and little significance has been given to GDP and its substance. As per Michael Todaro meaning of financial improvement incorporates both monetary and social decisions and recommends that improving way of life must ensure financial and social decisions and contends that advancement should “grow the scope of monetary and social decision to people and countries by liberating them from subjugation and reliance, not corresponding to others and country states, yet additionally to the powers of obliviousness and human hopelessness”.
Friedman characterizes monetary advancement “as an imaginative procedure prompting the basic change of the social framework” while Schumpeter characterizes improvement as far as a spasmodic and unconstrained change in the fixed state which perpetually modifies and uproots the harmony state beforehand existing”.
In 1990’s improvement financial specialists concentrated all the more legitimately on the advancement procedure. Mahbub-ulHaq, a main Pakistani financial analyst has commented, “The issue of improvement must be characterized as a particular assault on the most noticeably awful types of neediness. Advancement must be characterized regarding dynamic and inevitable disposal of lack of healthy sustenance, malady, ignorance, filthiness, joblessness and disparities. We are educated to deal with our GDP since it would deal with neediness. Let us turn around this and deal with destitution since it will deal with the GNP. At the end of the day, let us stress over the substance of GNP more than its paces of increment”.
In the United Nations Human Development Report (1994) a similar thought was featured. The report affirms: “Individuals are brought into the world with certain possible capacities. The reason for improvement is to make a domain where all individuals can extend their abilities, and openings can be augmented for both present and people in the future. The genuine establishment of human advancement is universalism in recognizing the existence cases of everybody.
Riches are significant for human life. Yet, to focus on it solely isn’t right for two reasons: First, aggregating riches isn’t essential for the satisfaction of some significant human decisions. Second, human decisions stretch out a long ways past monetary prosperity”.
Monetary improvement is subsequently an expansive idea which incorporates both financial and non-financial viewpoints. Alluding to the issue of improvement; Amartya Sen (1999) brought up that “Advancement requires the expulsion of significant wellsprings of unfreedom, destitution just as oppression, poor financial open doors just as orderly social hardship, disregard of open offices just as narrow mindedness or over movement of abusive states”.
In this manner, we presume that total and per capita genuine salaries are not adequate markers of monetary turn of events. Or maybe financial advancement is for two reasons: First, aggregating riches isn’t essential for the satisfaction of some significant human decisions. Second, human decisions stretch out a long ways past monetary prosperity”. Monetary advancement is worried about financial, social and institutional instruments that are important for getting enormous scope enhancements the degrees of living of the majority.
2.2.4 Measuring Economic Development
Monetary advancement being a multivariate idea having numerous measurements, there is no single proportion of improvement that totally catches the procedure. Unmistakably these markers or proportions of advancement ought to be substantial and amiable to estimation and correlation. Per capita salary has been one of the most punctual and furthermore a mainstream proportion of financial turn of events. A few financial experts have accentuated on certain social pointers as a measure of development, for example, levels of proficiency, wellbeing and business, while others have underlined on decrease in neediness as a significant marker of improvement. It has now become a typical practice to gauge advancement as far as composite lists, for example, HDI (Human Development Index), GDI (Gender Development Index), HPI (Human Poverty Index) and so on however per capita salary has been a generally utilized marker for estimating monetary turn of events. It is an essential pointer which estimates financial execution of a nation. Further, for estimating the pace of financial improvement national and worldwide organizations generally utilize per capita pay pointer and it has huge applied and measurable benefits. Per capita pay is the best single file which is promptly accessible and an effectively accepted measure for ordering nations into created and less created and might be utilized as an applicable beginning stage.
2.2.5 The Link between Political Institutions and Economic Institutions
2.2.5.1 The Different types of Political and Economic Institutions
In “Why Nations Fail”, Acemoglu &Robinson expect to clarify the varieties in cross-national financial advancement by concentrating on national level institutional components. They recognize four sorts of establishments: comprehensive political foundations, comprehensive financial organizations, extractive political establishments and extractive monetary establishments.
As per Acemoglu & Robinson, two components make a political establishment comprehensive: the level of centralization and the level of pluralism. Political foundations figure out who has power in the public arena and why that force can be utilized. On the off chance that that force is adequately dispersed across society and subject to limitations, at that point that foundation can be supposed to be pluralistic. Centralization then again decides the capacity of the state to uphold the standard of law, to help financial movement and to give security to its residents (Acemoglu & Robinson, 2012, p.94). Without such political or state centralization, the state can’t satisfy its most fundamental job, and the general public it administers is bound to “slide into mayhem” as Acemoglu & Robinsson have said. As an outcome, we allude to political organizations that are adequately brought together and pluralistic as comprehensive political establishments.
Following, Acemoglu & Robinson (2012, p. 144), “comprehensive financial organizations […] are those that permit and empower interest by the extraordinary mass of individuals in monetary exercises that utilize their gifts and abilities”. To be qualified as comprehensive, monetary organizations must component secure private property, a fair-minded arrangement of law, and an arrangement of open administrations that gives a level playing field in which individuals can trade and agreement. All things considered, comprehensive monetary organizations depend as much on the idea of majority as their political partners. Moreover, they should likewise allow the section of new organizations and permit individuals to pick their professions (Ibid, p.89). Comprehensive monetary organizations make comprehensive markets, which not just give individuals opportunity to seek after the jobs in life that best suit their gifts yet additionally give a level playing field that offers them the chance to do as such.
Extractive political establishments can be characterized as foundations where force is restricted, unconstrained, and amassed in the possession of a couple. Such organizations are exemplified by the absolutist governments ruling all through the world during quite a bit of history, or, for a contemporary model, North Korea’s tyranny. In line; with the previously mentioned meaning of comprehensive political organizations, in the event that either of the two measures is missing (pluralism and centralization of intensity) at that point the establishment can be qualified as extractive.
Extractive monetary organizations have the contrary properties to those we call comprehensive; they are intended to extricate livelihoods and riches from one subset of society to profit an alternate subset. By forestalling certain people to enter certain business sectors, or to practice certain callings, or by basically constraining them to take on unpaid work, for example, bondage, extractive financial organizations put an impediment to the free working of business sectors. Also, a state unequipped for or reluctant to implement property rights and agreements between private gatherings, and forestall extortion and burglary establishes an extractive framework, for it forestalls its residents to create, trade and participate in the economy in an ideal way. Given the focal job open merchandise and enterprises play in an economy, if the state neglect to give open frameworks, for example, streets and a vehicle organize, its monetary organizations don’t satisfy the necessities to be delegated comprehensive, and are thusly, in any event halfway extractive. In Acemoglu & Robinson’s words, extractive foundations obstruct the motors of thriving, or make them work backward (Ibid p.102).
2.2.5.2 The nexus between political institutions and economic institution.
There is a solid collaboration among political and financial establishments, as the idea of one impacts that of the other. All the more explicitly, Acemoglu & Robinson propose that there is causality from political to monetary organizations, implying that it is the idea of the political establishment that will thus decide the idea of the financial foundation of a given nation. Political pioneers can shape the monetary framework whenever the timing is ideal in an extractive political framework, given that they hold a lopsided measure of intensity. Accordingly, they will construct monetary organizations that permit them to extricate financial excess from the remainder of society, as the nonattendance of majority rule oversight over their activities doesn’t control their capacity to do as such. In that sense, while comprehensive establishments are commonly useful for the flourishing of a country all in all, a few people or gatherings are in an ideal situation by executing extractive foundations.
Extractive financial foundations in this way normally go with extractive political establishments (Ibid p.95). Actually, they intrinsically rely upon extractive political organizations for their endurance, on the grounds that comprehensive political foundations (vesting power extensively) would will in general evacuate financial establishments that dispossess the assets of the many, erect passage boundaries, and smother the working of business sectors with the goal that solitary a couple of advantage. Besides, due to the synergetic connection between extractive political and monetary foundations, a solid criticism circle fortifies this instrument. Undoubtedly, extractive political foundations empower the elites to pick monetary organizations with scarcely any restricting powers and limitations, while additionally empowering them to structure future political establishments and their development (Ibid p.96). Extractive financial organizations, thus, advance similar elites, and their monetary riches and influence help merge their political predominance. The elements supporting the idea of political and monetary organizations are hence favourable to recurrent and self-strengthening.
Additionally, regardless of whether new entertainers prevail with regards to getting through and accomplish power under an extractive political organization, they are moreover dependent upon just a couple of limitations since the structure of that establishment stays unaltered. Thus, they have motivating forces to keep up these political establishments and make a comparative arrangement of monetary organizations.
2.1.5.3 Extractive institutions and access to markets?
The sort of financial establishments that a country is liable to have is an immediate effect on the straightforwardness with which individuals can get to business sectors. The current segment looks to clarify the components by which comprehensive and extractive establishments adjust a people’s capacity to get to business sectors.
Under comprehensive monetary establishments, individuals are allowed to pick their calling, regardless of whether to begin a business or not, whether to contribute or not, notwithstanding having the certainty that their property rights are ensured. One could therefore say that opportunity is the foundation of comprehensive financial organizations. Comprehensive financial foundations make comprehensive markets, which not just give individuals opportunity to seek after the occupations in life that best suit their abilities yet in addition give a level playing field that offers them the chance to do as such. The individuals who have smart thoughts will have the option to begin organizations, labourers will in general go to exercises where their profitability is more prominent, and less proficient firms can be supplanted by more productive ones (Acemoglu&Robinson, 2012, p.91).
Interestingly, extractive financial organizations are portrayed by the efficient avoidance of specific people or gatherings from business sectors, while changing certain business sectors into “select jam”, for the advantages of the elites. Subjection gives a genuine case of an extractive monetary organization. Slaves are denied of their capacity to pick their calling and whether they need to enter certain business sectors; they are rather forced to partake in a profitable action.
Instruction possesses a focal job in Acemoglu &Robinson’s idea of extractive organizations. In reality, the last neglect to give satisfactory training to the individuals (due to inexistent or deficient open administrations), which leaves no decision for most residents however to fill in as poor, uneducated ranchers. As those establishments neglect to give enough aptitudes and training to their residents, the last are constrained in their decision when entering the work showcase, or are totally avoided from the last mentioned and rather participate in different types of work, for example, bondage or serfdom.
Syndications authorized by the administration, additionally called legitimate restraining infrastructures, comprise another type of avoidance from the market that is normal for extractive organizations. Eighteenth century Europe gives an away from of this, as blue-bloods determined the vast majority of their salary from landholdings and exchanging benefits allowed by the state. The failure for the vast majority to enter those business sectors converts into selective markets. In like manner, the difficulty for captives to claim land in European states in the Americas is a case of limited market.
2.2.5.4 The Role of Rent Extraction
A focal element of extractive financial establishments is their capacity to permit one or a few monetary specialists to extricate a lease from the remainder of society. As indicated by A. Smith, a lease is an unmerited pay or benefit harvested by the individuals who did not plant (Smith in Kaldor, 2007). Another meaning of lease is given by Lucian Bebchuk and Jesse Fried, who characterize the term as “[an] additional profits that organizations or people get because of their positional favourable circumstances” (Bebchuk et al. 2004, p.62).
Under extractive political organizations, political pioneers can execute strategies to grow their own riches and that of their family members, following a clientelism rationale. Instances of monetary lease incorporate import taxes, appropriations to specific divisions, or the inconvenience of guidelines on rivals so as to expand one’s piece of the overall industry. Defilement of open segment workers can likewise include an extraction of lease, for example, charge authorities who might accept hush money for diminishing the taxation rate of certain citizens. While lease looking for practices do exist in comprehensive institutional settings, they stay minimal contrasted with extractive ones. The purpose behind the wrongdoing of lease extraction in extractive institutional settings is the high grouping of intensity, and the absence of balanced governance on that power. On the off chance that limited first class to have all the political force and rule over an adequately concentrated country, it can demand favours and take kickbacks in return for assurance and legitimate acknowledgment over one’s action or business.
Conversely, under comprehensive political foundations, lease looking for conduct is precluded and battled against because of the capacity of residents to utilize their political capacity to do as such. To be sure, financial rents are by definition unmerited, and are removed from the economy by monetary specialists who didn’t add to their creation, which make them unwanted. Assuming that those rents are adequately obvious so a great many people have distinguished them, individuals will utilize their lawful rights to demand the nullification of such lease extractions.
Moreover, as comprehensive monetary establishments make and continue comprehensive markets, rents are not practical under them, because of the presence of rivalry. On the off chance that an individual or gathering of people extricates a lease from a specific movement, by setting a cost surpassing the market cost, different providers will assume control over his piece of the pie by setting a lower cost. The free section and exit of business sectors puts an impediment to any lease looking for action.
2.2.5.5 The impact of extractive institutions on economic growth and development
A definitive goal of Acemoglu&Robinson’s examination of organizations is to give a clarification to the determinant of long haul financial development, and by a similar token, to clarify the dissimilarity of development across nations throughout history. The focal proposition of “Why Nations Fail” is that financial development and thriving are related with comprehensive monetary and political foundations, while extractive organizations normally lead to stagnation and neediness. The current area clarifies the instruments supporting the previously mentioned forms. Comprehensive financial foundations offer the best conditions for monetary improvement for a few reasons. Under such organizations, individuals are allowed to pick their calling, labourers will in general go to exercises where their profitability is more noteworthy, and the individuals who have smart thoughts will have the option to begin organizations. Secure private property rights (which are an element of comprehensive foundations) are fundamental to monetary achievement, since just those with such rights will contribute and expand efficiency. Besides, open merchandise, for example, street are related with more prominent trades and better assignment of assets, which are all keys to financial development.
Interestingly, extractive foundations can’t continue monetary development for broadened timeframes as a result of their failure to make sure about property rights and to cultivate exchange and advancement. They are intended to expand riches for the elites, yet not for a wide cross-segment of society.
In accordance with the neoclassic development hypothesis, mechanical change is the primary driver of monetary development (Todaro and Smith 2015, p.138-139). Over the long haul, including more capital and work is at last less significant than learning new advancements that expansion efficiency per individual and per unit of capital. Therefore, given that mechanical change results from development, it follows that a financial framework helpful for advancement is additionally helpful for monetary development.
Extractive organizations disappoint the procedure of inventive pulverization coming about because of innovative change by two channels: the absence of monetary motivating forces and opposition from the elites (Acemoglu&Robinson, 2012, p.144). The first is because of the way that without secure property rights, contributing is an unsafe game. On the off chance that the monetary prize from a speculation is risked by robbery or literary theft, a money saving advantage examination will show that such a venture is not justified, despite any potential benefits. The second originates from the propensity for political elites in extractive frameworks to oppose changes that reallocate earnings away from themselves and towards new organizations and people (Ibid, p105). To be sure, advancement and its subsequent monetary development makes the two champs and washouts, by a procedure named innovative demolition (Schumpeter in Acemoglu and Robinson, 2012, p.98). The previous replaces old creation forms with new ones, and new areas occupy assets from old ones. Comprehensive political foundations are better ready to adapt to these successive and troublesome changes than extractive political organizations, as there is a net increase for society in general and just a minority of the populace bears the expenses. As political force is comprehensively spread and the vast majority are in an ideal situation or if nothing else is most exceedingly terrible off, innovative devastation is less regularly and less seriously battled against under comprehensive establishments.
In this way, development pushes ahead just if not obstructed by the monetary failures who foresee that their financial benefits will be lost and by the political washouts who dread that their political force will be dissolved. It is correctly the last procedure which wins under extractive establishments, due to the broad political and financial force held by the elites empowering them to oppose innovative change.
2.3 Theoretical Framework
The importance of economic development has been a weight on antiquated political researchers. It has gained various implications and translations from various researchers, for example, Amartya Sen, Todaro, Coralie Bryant, and so on. Advancement is characterized by Todaro and Smith as a multi-dimensional procedure that includes significant changes in social structures, famous perspectives, and national organizations, just as monetary development, decrease of disparity, and destruction of supreme poverty. Most researchers propounded hypotheses concerning improvement, how it is accomplished and how it is blocked. These hypotheses are the Modernization hypothesis, the Dependency hypothesis and the Feminist hypothesis.
2.3.1 Dependency development theory
This investigation receives the reliance hypothesis as its hypothetical system. The Third World started, with the Dependency Theory, to add to advancement hypothesis and to have its voice heard globally, instead of to keep on relying upon got standards that was assume to offer the correct responses. The Dependency Theory negated the case of all inclusiveness for the improvement hypothesis, and introduced better approaches for clarifying the reasons of, just as proposing new procedures for underdevelopment issue in the Third World.
2.3.2 Foundations and Main Principles of the Dependency Theory
The establishments of Dependency Theory were laid in 1950s by the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC). Noticeable creators of this methodology had contended that, so as to make sure about a solid turn of events, nations ought to make conditions for improvement. For example, Raul Prebisch proposed that, a nation should take significant financial and political measures to make what he called as “states of improvement”. A few proportions of this sort are as per the following:
At first chiefs and proposition created by Prebish were acknowledged as delegate thoughts of the Dependency Theory. Notwithstanding, towards 1960s, another gathering of creators who professed to be new age of reliance scholars developed, contending that the Prebish Model neglects to mirror the real factors of the Third World. The conspicuous agents of New Dependency Theory are Andre Gunder Frank, Theotonio Dos Santos, Enrique Cardozo, Edelberto Torres-Rivas, and Samir Amin (Reyes, 2001).
Raul Prebish and the other reliance scholars, concurred, somewhat, with the traditional, and furthermore neo-old style, hypothesis, that unfamiliar exchange without question was useful to the two players occupied with it as merchant and exporter, as the rationale of “similar expenses” and “relative points of interest” decided. Be that as it may, they differ on a few grounds, and among them were:
The unmistakable ideas and places that portray the Dependency Theory are as per the following:
(i) The structure of the world economy and the example of relations between the two principle groupings of nations. An exceptionally little gathering of cutting edge Western nations on the one side, called the middle states, and an a lot bigger gathering of immature nations which were at the outskirts, called the fringe states.
(ii) The relationship as one of control and abuse by the couple of focus nations, and of powerless passive consent and reliance by the numerous fringe nations. Step by step the reliance came to be viewed as significantly more than unfamiliar exchange, including political, social, and innovative and money related reliance.
(iii) Development in the propelled industrialist nations did not consequently mean improvement for the immature nations related with them. Furthermore, in light of the prohibitive approaches and measures embraced by the mechanical nations, improvement in these nations fundamentally prompted underdevelopment in subordinate nations was the statement from the reliance school.
(iv) Although the rationale and effect of the idea of the connection among focus and fringe nations, or the effect of outside elements yet these components, however prevalent, were not in solitude in activity. There were interior factors that worked inside the fringe nation, and they added to a more grounded reliance as they had a significant hold on the economy, the general public and the commonwealth, and utilized it to their own and the middle nations’ benefits. These inner elements were essentially basic in nature; they identified with class structure and relations, personal stake groupings, organizations intended to serve the incredible, the rich and the powerful (Sayigh, 1991).
As can be seen hitherto, the Dependency Theory joins components from a neo-marxist viewpoint with Keynes’ financial hypothesis (Reyes, 2001). The neo-Marxism was encouraged into being and development as a basic response less to neo-old style thought as to standard Marxism, as comprehended, rehearsed and converted into political reality by Latin American socialist gatherings. The focal analysis was that the literary Marx was not applicable to the private enterprise of the twentieth century which had seen numerous adjustments in class power relations and direction since Marx’s time (Raghavan, 1994). Notwithstanding financial elements, non-monetary components influencing advancement and development are likewise critical much of the time. As Sayigh (1991: 58) appropriately recommends, “This included the plan of action to an authentic point of view and to the structure and substance of relations between the entrepreneur modern nations and the immature nations remaining at the primitive stage or somewhere close to feudalism and free enterprise. An overwhelming element of this relationship was the skimming by the provincial intensity of the monetary overflow produced in the colonized nation”.
2.3.3 Application of the dependency theory to the study
Dependency theory can offer an accommodating way to deal with examine the instance of the Franc CFA comparable to the current examination question. Reliance alludes to the deviated monetary relations between metropolitan social orders and non-European peripheries a factor bringing about the advancement of the previous to the detriment of the underdevelopment of the last mentioned (McMichael 2011, p.6). In the expressions of Andre Gunder Frank, a main creator of the reliance worldview; “[…] Underdevelopment is in enormous part the authentic result of past and proceeding with monetary and different relations between the satellite immature and the now-created metropolitan nations. At the point when we look at this city satellite structure, we locate that every one of the satellites […] fills in as an instrument to suck capital or financial overflow out of its own satellites and to station some portion of this excess to the world city of which all are satellites (Frank in McMichael 2011, p.7). The Franc CFA can be examined in a similar way, as its part states bring together the unfamiliar trade holds got from the fare of essential wares, to then put them in the tasks account made for them by the French depository. Taking a gander at the circumstance from a reliance point of view would prompt the end that France (the centre) removes monetary overflow from its previous settlements, which are at the fringe of the world framework. The Franc CFA nations’ underdevelopment is hence an impression of the way of their fuse into the worldwide entrepreneur framework. Reliance examiners likewise centre on how “northern states” can utilize the money related framework to hold extraordinary impact in building up nations’ economies (O’Brien 2013, p.157). The Franc CFA framework gives a decent outline of this procedure, as will be contended in the current examination.
2.3.4 Major Critiques of the Dependency Theory
While the Dependency Theory picked up advocates likewise in different pieces of the world during the 1970’s, it additionally got subject to numerous analyses. Among these, five lines of analysis appear to be of significance for the motivations behind this examination:
The primary line of studies of the Dependency Theory has concentrated on the way that “this hypothesis doesn’t give thorough observational proof to help its decisions. Moreover, this hypothetical position utilizes profoundly theoretical degrees of investigation” (Reyes, 2001: 5).
The second line of the evaluation blamed the Theory of giving an excess consideration to the job of outer ties and connections while diverting consideration from the elements of inward clash.
The third line of pundits has addressed whether the Dependency Theory despite everything have a bound together and intelligent message for now, taking into the realities that it mirrors the conditions and comprehension of the 1960’s, and it encountered a few divisions since its underlying inception.
The fourth line of investigates to the Dependency Theory had originated from some neo-traditional business analysts in spite of the fact that their number is shockingly little. These neo-old style financial specialists looked at reliance as a short lived division of Third World market analysts, guided more by ideological preference and additionally dependent on sketchy exploration. For example, T. Bauer contended that, the main financial framework fit for supporting improvement is free enterprise (Sayigh, 1991). He is busy with “The Four Little Tigers” in the Far East, and contended that in the event that they could create from a condition of reliance and underdevelopment, others also could accomplish that. On the off chance that they followed the course of entrepreneur improvement and figured and actualized the suitable strategies, fundamentally in light of a relationship considered “subordinate” with the propelled Western mechanical nations, as opposed to regardless of it, verifiably implying that the Dependency Paradigm can’t be utilized in clarification of advancement emergencies, the immature nations could arrive at a specific degree of advancement (Escobar, 1996; Kueger, 2000).
The fifth line of pundits is that “the reliance development considers attaches with trans-national organizations as being just inconvenient to nations, when really these connections can be utilized as methods for transaction of innovation. In this sense, recollect that the United States was additionally a settlement, and this nation had the ability to break the endless loop of underdevelopment” (Reyes, 2001).
To put it plainly, huge numbers of the individuals who analyzed the reliance writing reasoned that the reliance investigation demonstrated incapable to demonstrate its essential proposition deductively and unfit to show that reliance and advancement was inconsistent (Reyes, 2002).
While the Dependency Theory picked up advocates additionally in different pieces of the world during the 1970’s, it likewise got subject to numerous analyses. Among these, five lines of analysis appear to be of significance for the motivations behind this examination:
The principal line of studies of the Dependency Theory has concentrated on the way that “this hypothesis doesn’t give thorough experimental proof to help its decisions. Besides, this hypothetical position utilizes exceptionally conceptual degrees of investigation” (Reyes, 2001: 5).
The second line of the studies blamed the Theory for Dependency of giving an excessive amount of consideration to the job of outside ties and connections while diverting consideration from the elements of inside clash.
The third line of pundits has addressed whether the Dependency Theory despite everything have a brought together and reasonable message for now, taking into the realities that it mirrors the conditions and comprehension of the 1960’s, and it encountered a few divisions since its underlying commencement.
The fourth line of investigates to the Dependency Theory had originated from some neo-old style financial analysts despite the fact that their number is shockingly little. These neo-old style financial analysts looked at reliance as a momentary division of Third World market analysts, guided more by ideological inclination and additionally dependent on sketchy exploration. For example, T. Bauer contended that, the main financial framework fit for supporting improvement is private enterprise (Sayigh, 1991). He is busy with “The Four Little Tigers” in the Far East, and contended that on the off chance that they could create from a condition of reliance and underdevelopment, others also could accomplish that. On the off chance that they followed the course of entrepreneur improvement and detailed and executed the proper approaches, essentially due to a relationship considered “subordinate” with the propelled Western mechanical nations, as opposed to notwithstanding it, verifiably implying that the Dependency Paradigm can’t be utilized in clarification of advancement emergencies, the immature nations could arrive at a specific degree of improvement (Escobar, 1996; Kueger, 2000).
The fifth line of pundits is that “the reliance development considers attaches with trans-national enterprises as being just impeding to nations, when really these connections can be utilized as a methods for transaction of innovation. In this sense, recollect that the United States was additionally a settlement, and this nation had the ability to break the endless loop of underdevelopment” (Reyes, 2001).
To put it plainly, huge numbers of the individuals who inspected the reliance writing presumed that the reliance examination demonstrated incapable to demonstrate its essential proposition experimentally and unfit to show that reliance and improvement were contradictory (Reyes, 2002).
References
Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. (2012). Why nations fail. New York: Crown.
Agboli, C. (2015). Pourquoi un débat scientifique sur le franc CFA est-il tabou? . Récupéré sur www.lemonde.fr: http://www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2015/06/04/pourquoi-un-debat-scientifique-sur-le-franc-cfa-est-iltabou_4647272_3212.html#pJijBxjy7kOIwFUH.99
Aghion, P., Cohen, E., & Pisani-Ferry, J. (2006). Politique économique et croissance en Europe. Conseil d’analyse économique. Paris: La Documentation francaise.
Akhalbey, F. (2019). Kwame Nkrumah’s iconic 1963 speech on African unity. (History, Éd.) Récupéré sur www.face2faceafrica.com: https://face2faceafrica.com/article/read-kwame-nkrumahs-iconic-1963-speech-on-african-unity
Amah, J. (2020, March 15). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo. (L. Timothew, Intervieweur)
Amin, S., & Aloysius, A. (2000). Long Term Growth in the CFA franc Zone Countries . World Institute for Development Economics Research .
Banque de France. (2013). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015 ). Rapport annuel de la zone franc, Annex 1 and 2. Eurosystème .
BCEAO. (2014). Rapport annuel de la Commission Bancaire. Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.
BEAC . (2007). Convention de Compte d’Opérations de la Banque des Etats d’Afrique Centrale .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politiqque monétaire .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politique monétaire .
Bearce, D. H. (2010). Monetary divergence : Domestic policy autonomy in the Post-Bretton Woods Era . Michigan Studies in International Political Autonomy .
Bebchuk, L., & Fried, J. (2004). The managerial power perspective. Dans L. Bebchuk, & J. Fried, Pay without performance : the unfulfilled promise of executive compensation . Cambridge: Havard University Press .
Broz, J. L., & Jeffry, A. F. (2001). The Political Economy of International Monetary Relations. Annual Review Political Science , 317-343.
Bryman, A. (2012). Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
Burda, M., & Wyplosz, C. (2013). Macroeconomics : a European text. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Calvo, G., & Coricelli, F. (1993). Output collapse in Eastern Europe : the role of credit. IMF Staff Papers, 40 (1), 32-52.
Carlos, L. (2016, October 3). Entretien de Carlos Lopes sur RFI. Récupéré sur http://www.rfi.fr: http://www.rfi.fr/emission/20161003-afrique-carloslopes-onu-franc-cfa-economie-monnaies-zone-franc-royaume-uni-ue
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique, 66, 42-55.
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique (66), 42-55.
Central Intelligence Agency. (1994). Africa Review, Special Issue : Impact of CFA Devaluation in Francophone Africa. Directorate of Intelligence .
Cessou, S. (2015). Un ministre a-t-il le droit de dire tout le mal qu’il pense du franc CFA? Récupéré sur http://rue89.nouvelobs.com: http://rue89.nouvelobs.com/blog/ruesdafriques/2015/05/14/un-ministre-t-il-le-droit-de-dire-tout-le-mal-quil-pense-du-franc-cfa-234557
Claude, K. T. (2020, March 19). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Intervieweur)
Clément, J. (1996). Aftermath of the CFA Franc Devaluation . The International Monetary .
Combey, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2010). Les effets non linéaires de l’infliation sur la croissance dans l’UEMOA. Communication au Symposium de l’Institut monétaire de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (IMAO).Accra.
Cooper, F. (2002). Africa since 1940 : The Past of the Present. Cambridge : Cambrigde University Press.
Cooper, F. (2015). L’Afrique dans le monde : Capitalisme, empire, Etat-nation.Paris: Payot.
Couharde, C., Coulibaly, I., & Damette, O. (2011). Misalignments and dynamics of real exchange rates in the CFA franc zone. EconomiX, Working Papers.
Daly, J. (2014). Counterterrorism or Neo-Colonialism? The French Army in Africa.Récupéré sur jamestown.org: https://jamestown.org/program/counterterrorism-or-neo-colonialism-the-french-army-in-africa/
Dembélé, D. M. (2011). Table ronde sur le Franc CFA : Que faire de la zone économique et monétaire du franc CFA, la Zone Franc : Instrument de controle et frein au développement des économies Africaines . SciencePo Paris .
Dieng, C. (2015). Idriss Deby appelle les pays africains à se débarrasser du Franc CFA. Récupéré sur Afrik.com: http://www.afrik.com/idriss-deby-appelle-les-pays-africains-a-se-debarrasser-du-franccfa#YJ08iWjLKAEZcdJu.99
Folarin, S. (2020, February 26). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Intervieweur)
Frank, A. G. (1981). Reflections on the World Economics Crisis. Fund .
Frank, A. G. (1966). The Developement of Underdevelopment. London: Arnold .
Frey, L., Botan, C., & Kreps, G. (1999). Investigating communication : An introduction to research methods. Boston & Bacon: Allyn & Bacon.
George, A. L., & Bennett, A. (2005). Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. MIT Press .
Gill, S. (1993). Gramsci, Historical Materialism and Inteernational Relations . Cambrigde University Press .
Graeber, D. (2013). Dette, 5000 ans d’histoire. Paris: Les Liens qui libèrent.
Griffin, C. (2007). French Military Interventions in Africa : Realism vs. Ideology in French Defense Policy and Grand Strategy . International Studies Association .
Gulde, A.-M. (2008). The CFA Franc Zone : Common Currency, Uncommon Challenges. International Monetary Fund Books .
Hallet, M. (s.d.). The role of the euro in Sub-Saharan Africa and in the CFA franc zone. Economic and Financial Affairs, European Commission, Economic , 347.
Ibid. (2000). L’analyse des deux vagues de politiques monétaires restrictives en Russie de 1993 à 1999.
Ibrahima Jr, D. (2020, February 1). A Dakar, Kako Nubukpo appelle l’Afrique à rompre avec la “croissance sans développement”. Récupéré sur https://www.financialafrik.com: https://www.financialafrik.com/2020/02/01/a-dakar-kako-nubukpo-appelle-lafrique-a-rompre-avec-la-croissance-sans-developpement/
Kaldor, M. (2007). Oil and Conflict. London: Pluto Press.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
La France et l’outre-mer : un siècle de relations monétaires et financières. (1996). Actes du colloque tenu à Bercy (p. 695). Bercy: Comité pour l’histoire économique et financière de la France.
Lelart, M. (2003). L’Union monétaire en Afrique de l’Ouest. L’Economie politique , 19 (3), 106-112.
Massimo, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2020, Mars). Una nuova moneta per gli Stati dell’Ovest. Le condizioni teoriche e politiche della sua fattibilita. Moneta e Credito .
Mbaye, A. A., & Mballa, C. (2019). La zone Franc d’hier à aujourd’ui. Interventions économques : Papers i,n Political economy .
Mborg, R. (2015). Le franc CFA freine le développement de l’Afriqque. Le Monde .
McMichael, P. (2011). Development and Social Change : A Global Perspective . SAGE Publications .
Messanh, N. L. (2017, March 13). Le Togolais Kako Nubukpo primé pour son ouvrage « L’envol de l’Epervier : le défi de l’émergence togolaise ». Consulté le August 4, 2020, sur financialafrik: https://www.financialafrik.com/2017/03/13/le-togolais-kako-nubukpo-prime-pour-son-ouvrage-lenvol-de-lepervier-le-defi-de-lemergence-togolaise/
Minart, G. (2016). Jaquier Rueff : Un liberal francais.Paris: Odile Jacob.
Mundell, R. (1961). A theory of optimum currency areas. American Economic Review (4).
Ndongo, S. S. (2017, July 12). Firoz Lalji Centre for Africa.Consulté le July 27, 2020, sur https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/africaatlse/2017/07/12/the-cfa-franc-french-monetary-imperialism-in-africa/
Nkrumah, K. (1965). Neo-Colonialism, the Last Stage of imperialism.
Nubukpo, K. (2020, January 21). Eco et franc CFA : quatre mariages et un enterrement. Consulté le January 29, 2020, sur www.jeuneafrique.com: https://www.jeuneafrique.com/884260/economie/tribune-eco-et-franc-cfa-quatre-mariages-et-un-enterrement/
Nubukpo, K. (2016). Le Franc CFA et le financement de l’émergence en zone franc . 123-133.
Nubukpo, K. (2011). L’improvisation économique en Afrique de l’Ouest – Du Cotton au Francc CFA. Paris : Khartala.
Nubukpo, K. (2019). L’Urgence africaine : Changeons le modèle de croissance ! Paris: Odile Jacob.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : La gestion du franc CFA par la BCEAO. Politique africaine, 105, 70-82.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : la gestion du franc CFA par la BECEAO. Politique africaine (105), 70-82.
Nubukpo, K., & Deh, C. P. (2016). L’envol de l’épervier : le défi de l’émergence Togolaise. Lomé: Graines de Pensées.
Nubukpo, K., Belinga, M., & Dembélé, D. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la sevitude monétaire. Paris, France: La dispute.
Nubupko, K., Belinga, M. Z., Tinel, B., & Dembélé, D. M. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la servitude monétaire : A qui profite le franc CFA ?Paris: La Dispute.
Oatley, T., & Kindred, W. (2014). Handbook of the international political economy of monetary relations. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
O’Brien, R., & Williams, M. (2013). Global political economy. Palgrave Macmillan.
Ould-Ahmed, P. (1999). Politiques monétaires, comportements bancaires et crises de financement en Russie : les vicissitudes des années 1990. Revue d’études comparatives Est-Ouest,, 30 (2-3), 89-121.
Pape, L. D. (1998). L’impact des taux directeurs de la BCEAO sur les taux débiteurs des banques . Notes d’Information et Statistiques , 483-484.
Pigeaud, F. (2016). Une monnaie nocive pour les Etats africains. Médiapart .
Polzer, T. (2001). Corruption : Deconstructing the World Bank Discourse. Development Studies Institute, London School of Economics, Working Paper Series, 1470 (2320).
Profant, T. (2010). French Geopolitics in Africa : From Neo-colonialism to Identity. Perspectives, 18 (1).
Saint-Légier, R. (1956). La zone franc, mécanismes, problèmes internationaux. Annuaire francaise de droit international, 2 (1956), 260-27.
Shatz, H. J., & Tarr, D. (2000). Exchange Rate Overvaluation and Trade Protection : Lessons from Experience . The World Bank .
Shillington, K. (2005). History of Africa. Macmillian Publishers Limited.
Smith, N. (2013). What is ”neoclassical” economics?
Strange, S. (1988). States and markets. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Todaro, M., & Smith, S. (2015). Economic development. Harlow: Pearson.
Trésor Direction Générale. (2013). 40 ans d’histoire de la Zone franc – Principes et modalités de fonctionnement de la coopération monétaire. Paris: Ministère de l’économie, République Francaise .
UEMOA. (1973). Traité du 14 novembre 1973 constituant l’Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.Préambule.
United Nations Development Programme. (1997). Human Development Report . Oxford University Press.
United Nations. (2006). Human Development Report. Beyond scarcity: Power, poverty and the global water crisis. United Nations Development Programme. Palgrave Macmillan.
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Credit policy, inflation and growth in a financially repressed economy. Journal of Development Economics, (13).
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Interest rate management in LDC. Journal of Monetary Economics, 12 (12).
World Bank. (2017). GDP per capita growth (annual%). The World Bank Group.
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction
This chapter details the exploration procedure occupied with the whole undertaking. In particular, it contains the examination procedure received for the investigation and contains the accompanying zones: research structure, populace of the examination, test size and inspecting strategy, information gathering strategies, wellsprings of information, instruments of information assortment, legitimacy and dependability of instruments, real field work or contextual analysis, technique for information portrayal, techniques for information examination, operationalization of factors. The previously mentioned regions are clarified in full detail so as to illuminate the extent of study.
3.2 Research Methodology
This examination utilizes the subjective strategy which targets getting a point by point portrayal of perception, subsequently giving important and canny information. In a similar vein, this exploration work additionally connects with essential wellsprings of information, remembering for profundity meet, just as auxiliary wellsprings of information, which comprise of diary audits and paper articles. As inside and out meeting utilized in this examination, inquiries will be posed to the different interviewees. The interviewees would be permitted to verbally explain their very own musings and assessments as it identifies with the examination.
3.2.1 Research Design
This examination utilizes the contextual investigation approach. An examination configuration is the game plan of conditions for assortment and investigation of information in a way that means to join pertinence to the exploration reason with economy in procedure.”In actuality, the examination configuration is the calculated structure inside which examination is led; it comprises the outline for the assortment, estimation and investigation of data (Kothari, 2004, p.31).
Subjective examination is utilized to help uncover the complexities of lived encounters and social wonder that are not amiable to measurable investigation, control and disentanglement. The contextual analysis research technique is perfect if the analyst is contemplating a particular wonder top to bottom; and is keen on posing inquiries that start with ”how”, ”what”, or ”why”; when the specialist has little command over what is being considered, and when the focal point of study is on a contemporary marvel with some type of genuine setting (Yin, 2003).This examination utilizes the contextual investigation approach. An examination configuration is the game plan of conditions for assortment and investigation of information in a way that means to join pertinence to the exploration reason with economy in procedure.”In actuality, the examination configuration is the calculated structure inside which examination is led; it comprises the outline for the assortment, estimation and investigation of data (Kothari, 2004, p.31).
3.2.2 Population of the study
As indicated by Hanlon and Larget (2011, p. 7) a populace alludes to ‘all the people or units of enthusiasm.’ There must be in any event a solitary pattern or component of shared characteristic among members in a populace (Bartlett et al., 2001; Creswell, 2003). The target masses of this exploration are academicians, specialists in monetary turn of events, common society delegates.
3.2.3 Sample Size
The sample size in this research consists of individuals who have conducted research on the topic of the Franc CFA or have worked directly with organizations that have conducted research on the Franc CFA. For the purpose of objectivity, 3 respondents were selected at random. They include Professor Sheriff Folarin, a researcher, Professor and Head of Department of Political Science and International Relations, Covenant University, Mr. Kondo Tokpovi Vénunyé Claude, Researcher at the National Institute of Statistics, Economics and Demographics Studies, Lomé, Togo and Mr. Jules Amah, a member of the Togolese Civil Society, a student researcher in International Economy at the Department of Economics, University of Lomé.
3.2.4 Instruments of Data Collection
Inside and out meetings were planned as the essential information assortment instrument for this examination. Various experts were met to uncover reality and getting a direct point of view on what the Franc CFA and economic development is about.
3.2.5 Validity and Reliability of Instrument
This alludes to the degree at which the apparatuses occupied with an exploration work uncover a reliable result. This on a very basic level arrangements with the degree of truth or distort of information which is determined by drawing in the examination instruments. Here, the information assortment methods, procedures and devices are approved. Interviews were planned with specialists as a major aspect of the instruments of information assortment. Specialists in the field of financial aspects studies would be met. What’s more, the director of this work considered substance and significance of the meeting guide and gave her last endorsement.
3.2.5 Method of Data Analysis
The technique received for the examination of information is printed investigation. Meetings directed, would be translated by the specialist and the record exposed to printed investigation. Literary investigation is the strategy correspondence scientists use to portray and decipher the qualities of a recorded or visual message. Its motivation is to depict the substance, structure, and elements of the messages contained in messages. The significant contemplations in literary examination incorporate choosing the kinds of writings to be considered, getting fitting writings, and figuring out which specific way to deal with utilize in breaking down them. There are two general classes of writings which are records of correspondence (verbatim chronicles) and yields of correspondence (messages created by communicators)(Frey et al., 1999). In this examination, records of correspondence would be received. The examination is pertinent in illuminating the extraordinary discussion on the Franc CFA and its indistinct future in Togo and the Franc Zone when all is said in done.
3.2.6 The Study Issues
The Franc CFA Zone
Four adapted realities make it conceivable to describe the economy of the African nations ofthe franc zone: the low portion of intra-network exchange (15% against 60% inside the eurozone), the low seriousness in trade costs because of the misalignment of the genuine swappingscale of the CFA franc contrasted with the Euro), the endogenous apportioning of credit (the proportion “credits to the economy contrasted with GDP” is 23% against 100% inside the Euro zone), lastly the sole aim of value steadiness sought after by the two fundamental national banks of the franc zone (BCEAO for West Africa and BEAC for CentralAfrica) (Combey and Nubukpo, 2010).
This territory is not ideal in the feeling of Mundell, Kennen, McKinnon in the measure or it has not had the option to set up elective alteration components to the conversion scale, in case of exogenous stuns: without a doubt, there is an exceptionally low versatility of the elements of creation (work and capital), because of the insufficiency of the four opportunities of development (merchandise, administrations, individuals and capital); likewise, there is next tono adaptability in costs and wages, especially in the middle where the swelling rate is as of now extremely low, consequently making descending unbending nature in the overall value level; additionally, the local monetary market being undeveloped, the potential outcomes of nonbank financing are extremely restricted (Nubukpo, 2016, p. 123-133).
At long last, the two switches of financial strategy, the spending plan and the money are blocked. The spending plan, with the possibility that it totally “cleans” open accounts, has lost its countercyclical character. Actually, under the burden of ostensible intermingling models, it has become procyclical, in other words that in a time of somberness, there is no development, along these lines little duty income, and there is no cannot adjust the spending plan. Also, as you do not adjust the financial plan, you are significantly more obliged to bring down open spending, there is less development, accordingly, less assessment income and in this way no fair spending plan except if you make further dull cuts in broad daylight spending (Carré,2015, p. 42-55). This budgetary strategy has been portrayed as “budgetarian” since the beginning of the basic change supported by the IMF and the World Bank (Minart, 2016,p.291).
Therefore, there has been no financial boost strategy for more than thirty years, with indistinguishable results from those accomplished today by a nation like Greece. Grimness is a snare you never escape. On the cash side, the African nations of the franc zone are confronting auxiliary collapse, as prove by the centre expansion rate which has been zero for two decades, bringing about loan fees twofold digit real factors, denouncing any sensible chance of obtaining for profitable ventures. In truth, the primary target of the national banks of the franc zone is the resistance of the conversion scale CFA and the Euro. As it is not reasonably possible that such proof could get away from the advertisers of open strategies inside the franc zone, it is important to scrutinize the profound springs of this catch, to deconstruct the various interests of the entertainers and the institutional inactivities to the work, to disentangle the skein of the steadiness of this pilgrim and postcolonial money, in short to pose the fundamental inquiry that is worth to us, that of “what is the franc CFA the name?” (Nubukpo, 2007, p. 70-82).
This single money lined up with the Euro has numerous inadequacies for a landmass with a low segment change and an extremely inadequate degree of monetary turn of events. Money related steadiness, low expansion, and the nonappearance of cash chance have contributed little to advancement. The nations in the region experienced poor per capita development. This excessively solid cash does not address the issues of these nations, which must line up with the somberness approaches rehearsed in the Euro zone to keep their swelling rate at European guidelines. This solid money additionally hurts African fares and energizes imports of unfamiliar made and agrarian items, demolishing the mechanical and horticultural advancement endeavors of the franc zone. The nations of the zone are subsequently kept up in a place of exporters of crude materials and their receipts rely upon world market costs and the Euro/Dollar conversion scale. Aggregating unfamiliar trade saves, these nations radically check the circulation of credit to the economy, which squares venture. Credit to the poor is extremely proportioned and frequently offered at financing costs of around 10%. Then again, this solid cash would permit the wealthiest Africans to profit by a trade ensure on their money related and land interests in France and in the world.(Nubukpo, Lawson and Sodji, 2015).
Togo and CFA Zone
The structure of the Togolese economy, notwithstanding a slim layer of refinement, is generally immature. Agribusiness, ranger service and fisheries utilize around 70% of the workforce, however contribute minimal in excess of a fourth of gross residential creation (GDP). The innovation utilized reaches from crude means farming in the inside of the nation to ranches set up by previous provincial bosses. The fundamental fare crops are coffee, cocoa and cotton, which speak to roughly a fourth of fares and around 10 percent of government incomes; albeit a high extent of cocoa is snuck from Ghana and is a record of Ghanaian shakiness, not Togolese methodologies. The conditions for the creation of these crude materials have by and large crumbled, because of dry season, and the need that the Togolese government has given to food creation since the last part of the 1970s, particularly in the North. The administration expresses that the nation is independent in food, while it is genuine when the climate is poor and corresponding to far reaching lack of healthy sustenance, particularly in the nation.
The most significant item division is phosphate mining. It speaks to over 40% of fares and contributes about 17% of open incomes. During the 1970s, improved by record phosphate costs in trade advertises, the legislature left on a driven program of industrialization and auxiliary expansion of the gainful part that included material processing plants, traveller lodgings, extravagance, a steel factory and a treatment facility of oil. The administration has additionally since a long time ago elevated the aspiration to make Togo the ” West African Switzerland ” through the advancement of banking, the travel industry and different administrations, in light of hundreds of years old stores and business pirating that made it the ” Francophone Gambia. ” The ECOWAS finance for pay and improvement is situated in Lomé and the capital is the central station of significant universal meetings, which ought to be viewed as a conciliatory accomplishment for the president, yet the travel industry (in contrast to Gambia) stays frail.
By and large, the administration division contributes about portion of the GDP. Togo's unfamiliar exchange and financial movement measurements are famously problematic, for the most part because of mass pirating. The principle action of this movement has consistently been the fringe with Ghana, where farming and different items are snuck into Togo to exploit the convertibility of its money and the ease import structure which stays in solace and extravagance of shoppers to support distribution centre exchange. Consequently, the figures gave in this article are, best case scenario, sensible pointers of generally drifts as opposed to solid proportions of movement levels, and may not be acceptable pattern markers if the dependability of Togo's neighbours (and along these lines exchange and pirating of organizations) breakdown forcefully. Before, Togo has worked with an impressive deficiency in its obvious and undetectable exchange. This has been adjusted by awards, help and, all the more as of late, unfamiliar advances. Togo is an individual from the franc CFA fiscal framework. This gives the nation the benefit of a convertible money upheld, in the long haul, by the French Treasury, which ensures convertibility at 50 CFA francs in French franc before 1994 and 100 CFA francs in French franc after the 1994 debasement; this significantly confines the administration's capacity to obtain inside, in light of the fact that, at any rate officially, it is accepted that the spending plans of the nations having a place with the framework are adjusted. This prompts the marvel of deferral in the instalment of pay rates and different solicitations for the partner of instalments from Ghana or Nigeria with checks secured by the printing of more cash. The CFA channel is less inflationary yet in addition less straightforward, on the grounds that the consumption stifled is practically difficult to appraise. The franc CFA being fundamentally a monetary instrument, it is critical to check whether the impression of the nation's financial conditions impact the assessment of the Togolese. It is solid to take note of that the more the Togolese see that the nation is going in "a misguided course" and that the monetary circumstance of the nation just as their own everyday environments are "awful" or "exceptionally awful", the more they keep up that the franc CFA must be supplanted. (Afrobaromètre, 2019, p.3)
Two out of three Togolese (66%) state that the CFA franc benefits France more than the part nations of the franc zone like Togo and that the last ought to be supplanted. A greater part (54%) even proclaims "totally" concur with this proposition. On the other hand, short of what one out of four Togolese (23%) state that this money is an instrument of improvement for a nation like Togo and ought to be kept up (Afrobaromètre, 2019, p.2).
The franc CFA, a currency for the worst
African nations are commonly powerful. They have huge financial development potential. The trouble for their situation has never been to accomplish high development rates but instead to support them in the long haul, even with their monetary, political and climatic weaknesses. This clarifies the "rationalistic" nature of monetary development in Africa: times of financial extension are counteracted by times of financial constriction and the other way around. Monetary development in the nations of the franc zone follows this example: it has been unpredictable and feeble by and large.
A straightforward exercise makes it conceivable to understand the "persuasive" nature of development in the nations of the franc zone. Simply wonder how much decades have been "lost" on the monetary development side. Let us call "lost decades" those for which the normal development of genuine GDP per capita was negative or zero. For instance, we will say that the time of 1960 has been "lost" if the genuine GDP per capita in 1970 is not exactly or equivalent to the genuine GDP per capita in 1960. For the eight WAEMU nations, insights on the advancement of genuine GDP per capita have been finished since freedom with the exception of Mali and Guinea-Bissau, for which the arrangement start during the 1970s (five noticeable decades for every one of them, thusly thirty perceptible decades altogether). It ought to be noticed that Mali left the franc zone somewhere in the range of 1962 and 1984 (in this way three perceptible decades) while Guinea-Bissau went along with it in 1997 (one discernible decade: 2000-2010). Out of a sum of thirty-four recognizable decades, thirteen have been "lost", or 38%.
For the six CEMAC nations, the arrangements are finished in the course of the most recent five decades with the exception of the Equatorial Guinea (where they started in 1980; this nation joined the franc zone in 1985, consequently three decades recognizable). Of the twenty-eight discernible decades, fourteen have been "lost", or half. For the Comoros, the arrangements are finished from 1980. Three recognizable decades have been "lost". By and large, each "lost" two decades as far as financial development. These incorporate the 1980s and 1990s, which saw the universal obligation emergency and the execution of auxiliary modification plans.
As a rule, the nations of the franc zone have once in a while had the option to get, over an entire decade, a normal development pace of genuine GDP per capita more prominent than or equivalent to 1% (twenty-three decades out of a sum of sixty-five recognizable decades, or 35%). It is not unexpected, participation in the franc zone rhymes with low normal monetary development. Over the reference time frame 1960-2014:
- Four nations had negative development in genuine GDP per capita: Comoros (- 0.4% somewhere in the range of 1970 and 2014), Central African Republic, Niger and Senegal.
- Six nations had positive for each capita genuine GDP development however under 1%: Benin, Cameroon, Ivory Coast, Guinea-Bissau (0.1% somewhere in the range of 1970 and 2014), Chad and Togo.
- Four nations had a development in genuine GDP per capita somewhere in the range of 1% and 2%: Congo, Burkina Faso, Gabon and Mali (1.4% somewhere in the range of 1967 and 2014).
- A solitary nation with a genuine GDP for every capita development of over 2%: Equatorial Guinea (11.2% somewhere in the range of 1980 and 2014).
As far as financial development, Equatorial Guinea is along these lines the main example of overcoming adversity that the franc zone can flaunt. Lamentably, this little oil nation is definitely not a model of improvement. The point is that the most extravagant nation in Africa (and significantly more extravagant than Spain, its previous colonizer, when its GDP per capita is estimated as far as buying power equality) is as yet grouped among the LDCs - the Least evolved nations! Showed improvement over the African normal? At the point when we look at the monetary exhibition of the nations of the franc zone with the middle financial presentation in sub-Saharan Africa, the fundamental perception is that the FCFA is cash for the more terrible, not to improve things. At the point when sub-Saharan Africa develops, most of nations in the franc zone frequently linger behind. The 1960s and 2000s were so far the greatest decades for sub-Saharan Africa. Just three nations in the franc zone had the option to transcend the middle in the principal time frame; four nations in the second. At the point when sub-Saharan Africa does severely, the franc zone battles as well, yet a couple of its individuals are doing generally "better". Eight nations of the franc zone performed superior to the middle during the 1980s, the most exceedingly awful of decades for both the mainland and the franc zone.
References
Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. (2012). Why nations fail. New York: Crown.
Agboli, C. (2015). Pourquoi un débat scientifique sur le franc CFA est-il tabou? .Retrieved from www.lemonde.fr: http://www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2015/06/04/pourquoi-un-debat-scientifique-sur-le-franc-cfa-est-iltabou_4647272_3212.html#pJijBxjy7kOIwFUH.99
Aghion, P., Cohen, E., & Pisani-Ferry, J. (2006). Politique économique et croissance en Europe. Conseil d’analyse économique. Paris: La Documentation francaise.
Akhalbey, F. (2019). Kwame Nkrumah’s iconic 1963 speech on African unity.(History, Ed.) Retrieved from www.face2faceafrica.com: https://face2faceafrica.com/article/read-kwame-nkrumahs-iconic-1963-speech-on-african-unity
Amah, J. (2020, March 15). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo. (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Amin, S., & Aloysius, A. (2000). Long Term Growth in the CFA franc Zone Countries . World Institute for Development Economics Research .
Banque de France. (2013). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015 ). Rapport annuel de la zone franc, Annex 1 and 2. Eurosystème .
BCEAO. (2014). Rapport annuel de la Commission Bancaire. Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.
BEAC . (2007). Convention de Compte d’Opérations de la Banque des Etats d’Afrique Centrale .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politiqque monétaire .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politique monétaire .
Bearce, D. H. (2010). Monetary divergence : Domestic policy autonomy in the Post-Bretton Woods Era . Michigan Studies in International Political Autonomy .
Bebchuk, L., & Fried, J. (2004). The managerial power perspective. In L. Bebchuk, & J. Fried, Pay without performance : the unfulfilled promise of executive compensation . Cambridge: Havard University Press .
Broz, J. L., & Jeffry, A. F. (2001). The Political Economy of International Monetary Relations. Annual Review Political Science , 317-343.
Bryman, A. (2012). Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
Burda, M., & Wyplosz, C. (2013). Macroeconomics : a European text. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Calvo, G., & Coricelli, F. (1993). Output collapse in Eastern Europe : the role of credit. IMF Staff Papers, 40 (1), 32-52.
Carlos, L. (2016, October 3). Entretien de Carlos Lopes sur RFI.Retrieved from http://www.rfi.fr: http://www.rfi.fr/emission/20161003-afrique-carloslopes-onu-franc-cfa-economie-monnaies-zone-franc-royaume-uni-ue
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique, 66, 42-55.
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique (66), 42-55.
Central Intelligence Agency. (1994). Africa Review, Special Issue : Impact of CFA Devaluation in Francophone Africa. Directorate of Intelligence .
Cessou, S. (2015). Un ministre a-t-il le droit de dire tout le mal qu’il pense du franc CFA?Retrieved from http://rue89.nouvelobs.com: http://rue89.nouvelobs.com/blog/ruesdafriques/2015/05/14/un-ministre-t-il-le-droit-de-dire-tout-le-mal-quil-pense-du-franc-cfa-234557
Claude, K. T. (2020, March 19). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Clément, J. (1996). Aftermath of the CFA Franc Devaluation . The International Monetary .
Combey, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2010). Les effets non linéaires de l’infliation sur la croissance dans l’UEMOA. Communication au Symposium de l’Institut monétaire de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (IMAO).Accra.
Cooper, F. (2002). Africa since 1940 : The Past of the Present. Cambridge : Cambrigde University Press.
Cooper, F. (2015). L’Afrique dans le monde : Capitalisme, empire, Etat-nation.Paris: Payot.
Couharde, C., Coulibaly, I., & Damette, O. (2011). Misalignments and dynamics of real exchange rates in the CFA franc zone. EconomiX, Working Papers.
Daly, J. (2014). Counterterrorism or Neo-Colonialism? The French Army in Africa. Retrieved from jamestown.org: https://jamestown.org/program/counterterrorism-or-neo-colonialism-the-french-army-in-africa/
Dembélé, D. M. (2011). Table ronde sur le Franc CFA : Que faire de la zone économique et monétaire du franc CFA, la Zone Franc : Instrument de controle et frein au développement des économies Africaines . SciencePo Paris .
Dieng, C. (2015). Idriss Deby appelle les pays africains à se débarrasser du Franc CFA.Retrieved from Afrik.com: http://www.afrik.com/idriss-deby-appelle-les-pays-africains-a-se-debarrasser-du-franccfa#YJ08iWjLKAEZcdJu.99
Folarin, S. (2020, February 26). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Frank, A. G. (1981). Reflections on the World Economics Crisis. Fund .
Frank, A. G. (1966). The Developement of Underdevelopment. London: Arnold .
Frey, L., Botan, C., & Kreps, G. (1999). Investigating communication : An introduction to research methods. Boston & Bacon: Allyn & Bacon.
George, A. L., & Bennett, A. (2005). Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. MIT Press .
Gill, S. (1993). Gramsci, Historical Materialism and Inteernational Relations . Cambrigde University Press .
Graeber, D. (2013). Dette, 5000 ans d’histoire. Paris: Les Liens qui libèrent.
Griffin, C. (2007). French Military Interventions in Africa : Realism vs. Ideology in French Defense Policy and Grand Strategy . International Studies Association .
Gulde, A.-M. (2008). The CFA Franc Zone : Common Currency, Uncommon Challenges. International Monetary Fund Books .
Hallet, M. (n.d.). The role of the euro in Sub-Saharan Africa and in the CFA franc zone. Economic and Financial Affairs, European Commission, Economic , 347.
Ibid. (2000). L’analyse des deux vagues de politiques monétaires restrictives en Russie de 1993 à 1999.
Ibrahima Jr, D. (2020, February 1). A Dakar, Kako Nubukpo appelle l’Afrique à rompre avec la “croissance sans développement”.Retrieved from https://www.financialafrik.com: https://www.financialafrik.com/2020/02/01/a-dakar-kako-nubukpo-appelle-lafrique-a-rompre-avec-la-croissance-sans-developpement/
Kaldor, M. (2007). Oil and Conflict. London: Pluto Press.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
La France et l’outre-mer : un siècle de relations monétaires et financières. (1996). Actes du colloque tenu à Bercy (p. 695). Bercy: Comité pour l’histoire économique et financière de la France.
Lelart, M. (2003). L’Union monétaire en Afrique de l’Ouest. L’Economie politique , 19 (3), 106-112.
Massimo, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2020, Mars). Una nuova moneta per gli Stati dell’Ovest. Le condizioni teoriche e politiche della sua fattibilita. Moneta e Credito .
Mbaye, A. A., & Mballa, C. (2019). La zone Franc d’hier à aujourd’ui. Interventions économques : Papers i,n Political economy .
Mborg, R. (2015). Le franc CFA freine le développement de l’Afriqque. Le Monde .
McMichael, P. (2011). Development and Social Change : A Global Perspective . SAGE Publications .
Messanh, N. L. (2017, March 13). Le Togolais Kako Nubukpo primé pour son ouvrage « L’envol de l’Epervier : le défi de l’émergence togolaise ».Retrieved August 4, 2020, from financialafrik: https://www.financialafrik.com/2017/03/13/le-togolais-kako-nubukpo-prime-pour-son-ouvrage-lenvol-de-lepervier-le-defi-de-lemergence-togolaise/
Minart, G. (2016). Jaquier Rueff : Un liberal francais.Paris: Odile Jacob.
Mundell, R. (1961). A theory of optimum currency areas. American Economic Review (4).
Ndongo, S. S. (2017, July 12). Firoz Lalji Centre for Africa. Retrieved July 27, 2020, from https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/africaatlse/2017/07/12/the-cfa-franc-french-monetary-imperialism-in-africa/
Nkrumah, K. (1965). Neo-Colonialism, the Last Stage of imperialism.
Nubukpo, K. (2020, January 21). Eco et franc CFA : quatre mariages et un enterrement.Retrieved January 29, 2020, from www.jeuneafrique.com: https://www.jeuneafrique.com/884260/economie/tribune-eco-et-franc-cfa-quatre-mariages-et-un-enterrement/
Nubukpo, K. (2016). Le Franc CFA et le financement de l’émergence en zone franc . 123-133.
Nubukpo, K. (2011). L’improvisation économique en Afrique de l’Ouest – Du Cotton au Francc CFA. Paris : Khartala.
Nubukpo, K. (2019). L’Urgence africaine : Changeons le modèle de croissance ! Paris: Odile Jacob.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : La gestion du franc CFA par la BCEAO. Politique africaine, 105, 70-82.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : la gestion du franc CFA par la BECEAO. Politique africaine (105), 70-82.
Nubukpo, K., & Deh, C. P. (2016). L’envol de l’épervier : le défi de l’émergence Togolaise. Lomé: Graines de Pensées.
Nubukpo, K., Belinga, M., & Dembélé, D. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la sevitude monétaire. Paris, France: La dispute.
Nubupko, K., Belinga, M. Z., Tinel, B., & Dembélé, D. M. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la servitude monétaire : A qui profite le franc CFA ?Paris: La Dispute.
Oatley, T., & Kindred, W. (2014). Handbook of the international political economy of monetary relations. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
O’Brien, R., & Williams, M. (2013). Global political economy. Palgrave Macmillan.
Ould-Ahmed, P. (1999). Politiques monétaires, comportements bancaires et crises de financement en Russie : les vicissitudes des années 1990. Revue d’études comparatives Est-Ouest,, 30 (2-3), 89-121.
Pape, L. D. (1998). L’impact des taux directeurs de la BCEAO sur les taux débiteurs des banques . Notes d’Information et Statistiques , 483-484.
Pigeaud, F. (2016). Une monnaie nocive pour les Etats africains. Médiapart .
Polzer, T. (2001). Corruption : Deconstructing the World Bank Discourse. Development Studies Institute, London School of Economics, Working Paper Series, 1470 (2320).
Profant, T. (2010). French Geopolitics in Africa : From Neo-colonialism to Identity. Perspectives, 18 (1).
Saint-Légier, R. (1956). La zone franc, mécanismes, problèmes internationaux. Annuaire francaise de droit international, 2 (1956), 260-27.
Shatz, H. J., & Tarr, D. (2000). Exchange Rate Overvaluation and Trade Protection : Lessons from Experience . The World Bank .
Shillington, K. (2005). History of Africa. Macmillian Publishers Limited.
Smith, N. (2013). What is ”neoclassical” economics?
Strange, S. (1988). States and markets. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Todaro, M., & Smith, S. (2015). Economic development. Harlow: Pearson.
Trésor Direction Générale. (2013). 40 ans d’histoire de la Zone franc – Principes et modalités de fonctionnement de la coopération monétaire. Paris: Ministère de l’économie, République Francaise .
UEMOA. (1973). Traité du 14 novembre 1973 constituant l’Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.Préambule.
United Nations Development Programme. (1997). Human Development Report . Oxford University Press.
United Nations. (2006). Human Development Report. Beyond scarcity: Power, poverty and the global water crisis. United Nations Development Programme. Palgrave Macmillan.
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Credit policy, inflation and growth in a financially repressed economy. Journal of Development Economics, (13).
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Interest rate management in LDC. Journal of Monetary Economics, 12 (12).
World Bank. (2017). GDP per capita growth (annual%). The World Bank Group.
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA PRESENTATION
4.1 Introduction
This section presents the information gathered from the essential sources. Information gathered from the inside and out meeting are broke down according to existing writing. This part is isolated into various segments. Segment A presents information on the foundation data of respondents while Section B manages the conversation of discoveries.
4.2 Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ Bio-data
The foundation data of the respondents is introduced in this area. Bio-information broke down with the utilization of pie diagram incorporate calling and region of intrigue.
4.2.1 Analysis of Respondents by Profession
This diagram illustrates the gender distribution of respondents who were interviewed.
Table 1: Profession Distribution of Respondents
| S/N | DISTRIBUTION | FREQUENCY | PERCENTAGE (%) |
| 1 | Academics | 1 | 33.33 |
| 2 | Governmental Institution | 1 | 33.33 |
| 3 | Civil Society | 1 | 33.33 |
Figure 1: Displays the profession distribution of the respondents that were interviewed. Each of them represents 33.33% of the total number of people interviewed.
4.2.2 Analysis of Respondents by Area of study
This diagram illustrates the area of study of respondents who were interviewed.
Table 2: Distribution of area of study of Respondents
| S/N | DISTRIBUTION | FREQUENCY | PERCENTAGE (%) |
| 1 | International Relations | 1 | 33 |
| 2 | Economics | 2 | 67 |
Figure 2: Displays the area of expertise of the respondents that were interviewed. 67% goes for Economics and 33% goes for International Relations.
4.3 Analysis of Findings
This section analyses the data gathered from the in-depth interview in relation to the existent literature.
4.3.1 Analysis of Proposition 1
The Franc CFA has no significant impact on the economic development of Togo
A nation in West Africa, with a territory of 56,600 km2, Togo has a populace of 5,753,324 occupants in 2010. About 62.6% of the populace lives in country condition and the economy is vigorously subject to business horticulture and occupation that utilizes over 65% of the working populace. Helpless nation, Togo is positioned 162nd out of 187 as indicated by the 2011 Human Development Index (HDI). 62% of the populace lives underneath the neediness line broadly with more noteworthy destitution in provincial areas. (Nationale et al., 2011)
The principle financial exercises of Togo are agribusiness, the abuse of phosphate and exchange. Horticulture utilizes 66% of the populace and speaks to around 38% of GDP. Be that as it may, this is basically a resource agribusiness dependent on customary practices and subject to these ongoing years to the impulses of the climate and value vacillations. Societies’ crops have reliably experienced low yields and the exhibition of the principle send out harvests (cotton, espresso and cocoa) is declining. The creation of meat and fish is additionally low and the nation faces monstrous imports to meet its food shortage. The finishes of most recent financial investigations show that agribusiness will remain the principle wellspring of development and work in the close future (Nationale et al., 2011).
The discussion on the fitness of keeping up the franc of the African Financial Community (CFA), made on December 26, 1945, was relaunched in July 2015, after the drama identifying with the conceivable exit of Greece from the euro zone, the well known "Grexit". All the more for the most part, this discussion happens with regards to the reflection on the financing of the rise of African economies and its essentials as far as the level of liquidity of the economies. Several hypothetical and experimental approaches permit us to talk about the points of interest and detriments of keeping up the franc CFA in this specific circumstance. In like manner, a few orders (history, political theory, financial aspects, political human science, and so on.) have all the earmarks of being ready to manage this multidisciplinary reality that the franc CFA constitutes. From a carefully monetary perspective, four measurements, among others, permit us to identify the shapes of the franc CFA, considered as an apparatus for financial turn of events and development or, despite what might be expected, an instrument of idleness for the African economies of the franc zone. These are the measurements, which we will address progressively, identifying with the portion of intra-network exchange, value intensity, financing of the economy lastly the goal of development in the missions of national banks of the area (Nubukpo, Belinga, and Dembélé, Sortirl 'Afrique de la servitude monétaire, 2016).
· The weakness of intra-community trade
The share of trade between the economies of the West African Economic and Monetary Union (UEMOA) is structurally low, ranging between 10% and 15% from one year to the next (By way of comparison, this share is higher than 60% within the euro zone). This weakness in intra-community trade is only apparently surprising: in fact, insofar as the WAEMU economies maintain a primary insertion in international trade, they are more substitutable than complementary to one another. The typical example is cotton, 97% of its ginning fibre is exported without processing. However, six of the eight states that make up UEMOA, export cotton fibre. It goes without saying that there is little interest for Mali in exporting its fibre to Burkina Faso and vice versa, even as these States are looking for foreign currency to allow them to finance their imports of goods and services. In fact, the real extroversion of the WAEMU economies makes it almost irrelevant to share the same currency, in this case the franc CFA. (Nubupko, Belinga, Tinel, & Dembélé, 2016)
This observation is made by the former president-delegate of the French government's Economic Analysis Council, Christian de Boissieu, who considers that "the monetary stability organized within the framework of the franc zone has not really had any consequences significant on the growth of intra-African trade. So the real effects of monetary stability have been limited. It is clear that this non-take-off of commercial interdependence must be taken into consideration; it is due to international specializations, problems of competition and complementarities, etc. […]. It is clear that with the franc zone we did the opposite of what we want to do in Europe. In Europe, we started with the real economy and the single currency will be the crowning achievement. In Africa, we did the opposite, we started with monetary cooperation and we are ultimately waiting for economic integration, who will come or who will not. So it is an inverse transition, and it will be necessary to manage, to telescope or to articulate these two reverse transition patterns "(La France et l’outre-mer : un siècle de relations monétaires et financières, 1996). In any case, the question of the structural transformation of African economies is at the heart of this observation, insofar as only the upsurge in value chains will allow the economies of the franc zone to trade goods and services sufficiently diversified to generate an increase in the share of intra-Community trade.
- Price competitiveness of WAEMU economies at half mast
The WAEMU economies experience the ill effects of an issue of value seriousness in trades, because of the linkage of the franc CFA to the euro, a strong currency if there is one. In any case, solid money goes about as an expense on sends out and an appropriation on imports, making it hard to accomplish a reasonable exchange balance. The examination of the development of the Real Effective Exchange Rate (REER) underpins the past finding. Various observational investigations have along these lines featured an overvaluation of the franc CFA of around 10% (Kiema, Nubukpo, and Sanou, 2011) and (Couharde, Coulibaly, and Damette, 2011).
Without a doubt, the REER of the zone increased in value, which caused lost seriousness for the household economies. The investigation of the REER is fundamental to the extent that the last is a marker of worldwide seriousness, and its long deviations from its drawn out harmony pattern change showcase flags and actuate critical expenses customizably. Regardless of whether positive or negative, a misalignment of the REER mirrors a helpless swapping scale strategy and the allotment of gainful assets, which could prompt a delayed emergency, which could hamper improvement endeavours and development elements.
- Chronic underfunding of the economies of the franc zone
The economies of the franc zone are described by credit apportioning, the reasons for which allude as a lot to the concealed plan of the two fundamental national banks in the zone (the BCEAO for the UEMOA space and the BEAC for the CEMAC territory) than to the extraordinary hesitance of the financial framework in the zone. As to initially point, it is presently clear that the fundamental goal of the Central Bank of West African States (BCEAO) and its partner, the Bank of Central African States (BEAC), is the safeguard of the swapping scale between the franc CFA and the euro, considerably more than some other thought (value strength or financial development), as confirm by the constancy of the “Fiscal Program”. To be sure, before the progression of the money related framework in 1989, the oversight of bank credit in the WAEMU necessitated that the BCEAO distribute to every nation an estimate volume of credit to be conceded by the financial arrangement of that nation to its economy during a given year. This activity was completed each November at a gathering called the “Money related Program” which appropriately revered administration by amounts (volume of credit allotted to the different national financial frameworks) in a setting where costs (loan fees) had little effect. In any case, because of the basic to guarantee a story measure of unfamiliar trade, the “Money related Program” is as yet going on and keeps on dispensing an exact volume of liquidity to the economies through the national financial frameworks. Subsequently, the danger of drawing on the monetary forms of the national bank to back monstrous imports coming about because of opening the conduits of bank credit too wide is constrained, similar to any danger of downgrading of the franc CFA. We in this way end up in a framework where value the executives (loan fee) is hypothetically liable for controlling the volume of bank liquidity, yet where, in all actuality, the old arrangement of credit management proceeds. As to; second point, that of the frivolity of the financial framework, it is, at long last, just the end product of the first, specifically the sign of a budgetary repression hat fills fiscal constraint.
To be sure, a significant trait of the money related arrangement of the franc zone is the unequivocally oligopolistic structure of the financial part, comprising a factor of unbending nature of the loaning loan costs of banks (Pape, 1998). WAEMU banks don’t generally require the BCEAO to renegotiate to the degree that they are over-fluid, yet additionally receive conduct of unsaid or demonstrated comprehension, with the target of boosting transient benefit. This leads them to support the conceding of credit to State undertakings recently privatized or during the time spent being privatized, with high anticipated productivity, and to decrease their arrangement of long haul financing exercises and/or little and medium-sized organizations. In this unique circumstance, the incredibly low number of saves money with sub-provincial capital working in UEMOA and the liquidation of banks supposed “advancement”, cleared away by incessant helpless administration, forestall the activity of a genuine organization for the improvement of the region. The final product of these two perceptions, to be specific, from one viewpoint, the pre-prominence of the barrier of the conversion scale between the CFA franc and the euro over interior recurrent turns of events and, then again, endo-proportioning quality bank credit, is the constitution of extreme unfamiliar trade stores of national banks of the franc zone with the French Treasury. For the UEMOA zone, net unfamiliar resources as of December 31, 2014 added up to 5208 billion franc CFA for the BCEAO, or a money related issuance inclusion pace of 84.3%. For the CEMAC zone, net unfamiliar resources during a similar period added up to 8387.471 billion franc CFA for the BEAC, that is, an inclusion pace of the financial issue of 89.8% 7, through the component known as the “activities account” (Nubukpo K. , Politiquemonétaire etsubjugation volontaire : la gestion du franc CFA standard la BECEAO, 2007).
- The absence of a growth objective in the missions of the BCEAO
The BCEAO has picked an expansion focus of 2% as the principle goal of WAEMU's financial approach (The BCEAO in this manner professes to be more prudent than the Conference of Heads of State of the UEMOA, which has embraced swelling objective of 3% as a component of the macroeconomic combination criteria).Such a decision comes from the pegging of the franc CFA to the euro since this objective is the one picked by the European Central Bank (ECB). In any case, in a fixed conversion standard system with free development of capital, it is unthinkable for the BCEAO to have an enduring fiscal arrangement unique in relation to that of the grapple zone, in other words the euro zone, as per the exercises of the "Mundell triangle of incompatibilities"(Mundell, 1961). This institutional connection, acquired from the collaboration understandings among France and UMOA/UEMOA, in this way compels the BCEAO in its capacity to pick its money related arrangement objective. To be sure, in a fixed conversion scale system, swelling contributes, as a result of the loss of seriousness it creates, to the continuous crumbling of outside records and to the overvaluation of the swapping scale, in this way debilitating equality between monetary forms. Actually, the expansion focus of 2% embraced by the BCEAO, indistinguishable from that of the European Central Bank, appears to be basic taking into account the imperatives instigated by the presence of a fixed conversion scale between the two zones. This objective may not be hazardous on the off chance that we hold the rule that "what is useful for the euro zone is useful for the CFA zone". Nothing is less sure, notwithstanding, given the importance of this swelling objective for the euro zone, which is the objective of analysis from Keynesian financial specialists (Aghion, Cohen, and Pisani-Ferry, 2006), yet most importantly, here, as far as its significance for the zone. UEMOA: the difficulties confronting these creating nations are significantly more unpredictable and the expected commitment of the money to accomplishing monetary development ought to have the option to offer ascent to another kind of reflection. The appropriation of such an expansion target may in reality appear to be excessively prohibitive for economies that would require 7% GDP development to divide the destitution of their populations. Surprisingly, the BCEAO thinks so minimal about financial development and advancement. The exact writing on the inquiry is anyway productive. For instance, we can review that the concurrent quest for value steadiness and solid financial development energized the discussion on the Phillips bend (The Phillips bend assesses the compromise among swelling and joblessness: truth be told, it recommends that it is conceivable to acquire extra monetary development that ought to convert into lower joblessness, through an expansionary money related arrangement. The ascent in the pace of swelling, an outcome of expansionary money related approach, would be the cost to pay for development. Such a chain of instruments has been addressed by the monetarists who have appeared, because of the presentation of supposed versatile and afterward sane desires in Keynesian models, the nonattendance of compromise among swelling and joblessness. The reaction of the new Keynesians was to restore the Phillips bend through the theory of defective value adaptability.), for example on the need to exchange off between expansion and joblessness. Different observational examinations, completed specifically in the UEMOA zone (Combey and Nubukpo, 2010)and in the economies experiencing significant change (Calvo and Coricelli, 1993) (Ould-Ahmed, 1999), have additionally demonstrated that prohibitive money related strategies have a passive macroeconomic impact(Ibid, 2000) while neo-structuralism models stress the unreasonable impacts connected to embrace prohibitive fiscal approaches in creating economies(van Wijnbergen, Credit strategy, swelling and development in a monetarily stifled economy, 1983)(van Wijnbergen, Interest rate the executives in LDC, 1983). As the franc CFA is essentially a monetary instrument, it is imperative to see whether impression of the nation's financial conditions impact the assessment of Togolese. It is solid to take note of that the more the Togolese see that the nation is going in "a misguided course" and that the financial circumstance of the nation just as their own day to day environments are "terrible" or "extremely awful", the more they keep up that the franc CFA must be replaced (No and Akinocho, 2020).[1]
Figure 3: Maintaining or not the franc CFA due to changing in economic conditions in Togo, 2017.
Source: Afrobaromètre & Centre for Research and Opinion Polls (2019)
A national economy isn’t constrained to interior creation yet in addition outer creation, Togo produce inside and exchanges with different nations, as far as the effect of the franc CFA on the Togo’s monetary turn of events, the BCEAO has not set up an approach that favours nearby speculators to put resources into the national economy along these lines influencing the work division. The Franc CFA money related framework has strategy quantifies that don’t support the financial advancement of nations having it as cash, in this way causing low interior creation and high joblessness rate. With regards to exchange, the franc CFA does not permit Togolese products and crude materials to be serious on the worldwide market. The fixed equality between the franc CFA and the Euro makes it inconceivable for Togo to change the costs of its crude materials, influencing along these lines its exchange balance which is shortage (Claude, 2020).
The monetary effect of the franc CFA is interpreted as a neo-pioneer gadget that keeps on crushing any possibility of financial advancement in client countries. As per this point of view, the franc CFA is a hindrance to industrialisation and basic change, serving neither to invigorate exchange joining between client countries, nor support bank loaning to their economies. The credit-to-GDP proportion remains around 25% for the WAEMU zone, and 13% for the CAEMC zone, yet midpoints 60%+ for sub-Saharan Africa, and 100%+ for South Africa. The franc CFA likewise empowers huge capital surges. To sum things up, participation of the franc zone is equal with neediness and under-business, as prove by the way that 11 of its 15 followers are classed as Least Developed Countries (LDCs), while the rest (Cote d’Ivoire, Cameroon, Congo, Gabon) have all accomplished genuine term financial decay (Ndongo, 2017 in Claude, 2020). In term of positive impact, it is asserted that the CFA franc has permitted swelling to be pegged at a rate impressively lower than the African normal. For its faultfinders, be that as it may, the partner of this low expansion rate is powerless monetary development and the production of less jobs (Ndongo, 2017).
Pundits of the franc CFA keep up that enrollment of the franc zone are hostile to the development of majority rules system. To maintain the franc CFA, it is contended, France has never dithered to cast off heads of state enticed to pull back from the framework. Most were expelled from office or slaughtered for more agreeable pioneers who stick to control no matter what, as appeared by the CEMAC countries and Togo. Monetary advancement is inconceivable in such conditions, similar to the making of a political framework that meets the distractions of most of citizens (Ndongo, 2017).
For its partisans, conversely, the hidden rationale of the franc CFA lies not in neo-imperialism, yet in fiscal collaboration. The a work in progress of the franc zone countries is ascribed to factors autonomous of their financial and trade arrangements, specifically to their political shakiness and the poor monetary approaches of their leaders. The franc CFA is portrayed as a sound and stable cash, a huge uprightness given the experience of most money giving African countries. This counter-contention is, in any case, defective: experience shows that countries like Morocco, Tunisia and Algeria, which post autonomy pulled back from the franc zone and mint their own cash, are more grounded financially than any client of the franc zone countries (Claude, 2020).
The UEMOA has for goals to fortify the financial coordination of its part states, to elevate horticulture and to support rivalry in monetary exercises. Togo’s economy being founded on horticulture, with a GDP Per Capita PPP (Purchasing Power Parity) of 671.4 in 2019and a financial development of 5.1 percent in 2019; is a recipient of the Agricultural Program of the UEMOA. It targets building up the horticultural area. So the Togolese economy in the UEMOA zone approaches free development of merchandise and ventures; intra-local exchange at a Common External Tariff (CET). And furthermore the UEMOA is financing streets development and Hydraulic force vitality programs in Togo (Amah, 2020).
All things considered, intraregional exchange is low when contrasted with different traditions association; while ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) and the EU’s intraregional exchange adds up to around 25% and 60% of all exchange, separately, that figure is evaluated to lie beneath 15% for WAEMU, non-Tariff Barriers additionally obstruct intraregional exchange the locale. They include: exorbitant outskirt methodology; powerless administration; deficient vehicle foundation; helpless business condition; helpless usage of WAEMU rules of starting points, used to certify products as being of WAEMU inception and levy free (Initiative, n.d.).
From an untouchable subject raised uniquely by a bunch of African savvy people and government officials, the franc CFA banter is beginning to enter everyday discussion and to draw in the consideration of activists. A social development is creating to request the joint withdrawal of African countries from the franc CFA. On 7 January 2017, on the activity of ‘SOS Pan-Africa’ (‘Urgences Panafricanistes’), a NGO set up and run by the extremist Kemi Séba, against CFA showings were composed in a few African and European urban areas, and in Haiti. The mobilisations differed in size as indicated by nation, uniting erudite people, skillet Africanist and against globalization activists and others. SOS Pan-Africa has since given a representative intrigue for Africans to blacklist French items (Ndongo, 2017).
The money related strategy of the BCEAO and subsequently the administration of the CFA franc, without a doubt experience the ill effects of absence of contextualization of the job and missions of a national bank and cash, with regards to creating economies among the most unfortunate of the world, pitifully adapted and banked. It would be attractive for the BCEAO to show more realism, for instance by drawing motivation from selection of purported “eccentric” fiscal strategies by the national banks of industrialized nations, especially with regards to the “post-subprime obligation emergency” and the danger of worldwide deflation(Carré E. , 2015).
Hence, the above reactions from certain respondents, along with strands of existing writing answer the main examination question which states ” The Franc CFA has no huge effect on the financial advancement of Togo.” The investigation reacts to the affirmation that the franc CFA has no noteworthy effect on the monetary improvement of Togo by expressing the accompanying among others:
- The low portion of intra-network exchanges (15% versus 60% in Euro zone).
- The low fare value seriousness (because of the misalignment of the genuine conversion standard of the CFA franc against the euro).
- The endogenous apportioning of credit (the proportion of ”credits to the economy to GDP” is 23% versus 100% inside the euro zone).
- The just target of value dependability sought after by the two primary national banks of the franc zone (BCEAO for West Africa and BEAC for Central Africa).
In light of the above, the first research proposition which states that the CFA franc has no significant impact on the economic development of Togo is falsified.
4.3.2 Analysis of Proposition 2
Togo’s economic development lays out of the Franc Zone
In Dakar, confronting financial experts, Kako Nubukpo approached Africa to break with development without improvement for another model equipped for making employments. This African development is not adequately comprehensive, underlines Mr. Nubukpo, for reasons notable in the monetary writing, specifically the essential addition in worldwide exchange. With the goal that African development can be solid in pattern and unpredictable during the rhythms of crude materials. This expansion does not adequately change the crude material (Ibrahima Jr, 2020).
What space for move does Togo have, in a setting of interior and outer changes, to fabricate an ideal direction of development? The consistent and gigantic obligation procedure of African states during the 1960s and 1970s, stemming both from the developmentalist state worldview and from the incessant terrible administration of open specialists, finished in a stalemate. This clarifies the appearance of Structural Adjustment Programs, with a lot of tearing the social texture since the 1980s. The downgrading of the franc CFA in 1994 was even more difficult for Togo as the nation didn’t profit by the help estimates set up somewhere else in light of the fact that at the time it was endorsed and expelled by the benefactor network for popularity based shortfall; which features the multifaceted idea of any procedure of development which cannot be diminished to the sole auxiliary change of the economy. Social, political, institutional and cultural administration viewpoints outweigh everything else. Regardless, their enunciation makes it conceivable to characterize the significant patterns and the seeds of progress prone to portray the potential directions, and, among the last mentioned, to educate and extend those ideal by the whole populace based on an openly characterized aggregate vision. Will the energy propelled in 2006 by the Togolese specialists, focusing on solid and comprehensive development be adequate to meet the desires for a developing youth? (Nubukpo and Deh, L’envol de l’épervier : le défi de l’émergenceTogolaise, 2016)
Without anyone else, the segment challenge, in a setting of the delicacy of normal biological systems and the expansion in uncertainties, gives the proportion of the reactions to be given as far as physical framework, training, human limit building, and huge formation of business. Starting here, if Togo figures out how to climb onto a feasible way of development, it can, in different regards, fill in as a model for all sub-Saharan nations (Messanh, 2017). But would he be able to arrive outside the franc zone? Togo is subject to its neighbours as far as exchange and monetary mix; along these lines in the event that it needs to pull out of the franc zone, it must be finished with others (Folarin, 2020).
Sway assigns the predominance of control over a geological region or over a gathering of people groups living in network. Along these lines, in a majority rule government, it is possessed by the individuals. Regardless of a difference in restorative name which did not affect its abbreviation, the franc CFA whose fixed equality with the Euro keeps on being ensured by the French open depository, driving fifteen nations which despite everything use it to store in any event 50 percent of their unfamiliar trade saves in the tasks account housed at the Banque de France is progressively observed as a striking outline of the monetary and political extraversion power that portrays African social orders in the franc zone. Under these conditions, African states are not in the ability to choose their financial approach, accordingly assigning to the previous frontier influence one of the vital components of sway, which is the ability to mint money (Nubukpo K. , L’Urgenceafricaine : Changeons le modèle de croissance !, 2019).
This circumstance perseveres for two effectively recognizable reasons: the alleged solidness of this cash because of its peg to the euro, counterfeit dependability since it fills the unsteadiness of the genuine division of the economy because of the proportioning of beneficial credit; the way that this money serves the premiums of savage elites who spare in the euro zone, in this manner leaning toward lease private enterprise to a reinvestment of capital in their individual nations while calling for new financing procedures (the acclaimed Marshall Plan for Africa) consequently assisting with developing somewhat more every day the pot of monetary re-appropriating (Amah, 2020).Under these conditions, it appears to be authentic to argue for fiscal sway, not by trying to deliberately restrict the administered and the overseeing or even by holding fast to an enemy of French talk. It is significant that the French-speaking African States of tomorrow are completely overseers of their fiscal and monetary arrangements, and in this manner have the option to pick completely and in inner voice the fate of their nation with a worry for comprehensive development (Folarin, 2020).
Money is an all out social reality. The difference in the abbreviation franc CFA will not take care of the considerable number of issues that Africans around there are confronting, yet there is an image and a subjective jump to be taken: it is absolute opportunity from France so tomorrow it might be conceivable to assemble together win-win associations planned on an equivalent premise, picked on serious measures and in complete break with this pioneer residue (Nubukpo K. , L’Urgenceafricaine : Changeons le modèle de croissance !, 2019). Picking sway isn’t promising the large night. There won’t be an extreme improvement in the lives of the most defenceless, yet it is a noteworthy initial step to state that they are not overlooked and that their desires are at the core of the worries of this change. There will consistently be endeavours to steal cash; however this new task proposes to control them to serve all so as to escape deliberate subjugation for an intentional and comprehensive financial approach. Sway must be the fair articulation of the best number. Be that as it may, what do we see today? While the two fundamental national banks of the franc zone acquired their autonomy from the states in 2010, one would have anticipated that they should haggle legitimately with their partner in Frankfurt, the European Central Bank. Indeed, it isn’t, they should experience the French Treasury, in other words the French Ministry of Finance, to get to the assurance of the fixed equality between the CFA franc and the euro (Nubukpo K. , L’Urgenceafricaine : Changeons le modèle de croissance !, 2019). At last, the French franc done existing, having been supplanted by the euro, it might appear to be amazing that African chiefs are turning out to be more ” traditionalist than the ruler ”, by battling savagely to keep a unit of record regarded old by its own makers. This deliberate bondage could have been the cost to pay to accomplish solid and comprehensive development. Lamentably, it isn’t and, obviously right now, there is no positive effect of macroeconomic approaches on the lives of populaces inside African nations of the franc zone. From a carefully lawful perspective, it would likewise be helpful to solicit whether France’s summon from the rule of subsidiary so as to have the option to keep up the money related plan which ties it to the African states during the Maastricht Treaty in 1992, is undeniably lawful and dissect the layouts of the duties accepted by the other part conditions of the euro zone, whose cash establishes the stowage of the CFA franc. Money is a component of power and, in that capacity, offers ascend to energetic discussions on the substance and forms of this sway, particularly in the supranational structure of the financial associations inside the franc zone (Folarin, 2020).
As should be obvious, every one of these subjects contain inside them, the raise of a genuine examination program identifying with the eventual fate of the franc CFA, which the political and money related specialists, the scholastics and exploration focuses of the franc zone would be respected to advance, in this manner pointing just at the quest for the overall premium. At last, the Franc zone is an amazing vector for the aggregation of riches outside of it, in this manner fuelling the solid extroversion of French-speaking African economies. This stems from three of its fundamental attributes: the fixed equality between the franc CFA and the euro, the all out assurance of convertibility between the franc CFA and the euro, lastly the free development of capital between the franc zones and euro. To watch intently the working of this zone, one can talk about wilful money related subjugation. It is African governments themselves who acknowledge the standards of the fiscal game. It is too simple to even think about sharing or pass on the possibility that the franc CFA is a piece of a type of French plot against Africa. The legislatures of the CFA zone have an individual enthusiasm for staying in the possession of the French Treasury (Messanh, 2017). The offices offered by this zone regarding bringing in purchaser merchandise and moving capital support a genuine outgoing economy to be supported. Also, the specialists have decided to store unfamiliar cash holds with the French Treasury for a sum well over the necessary level. Be that as it may, this space for move could have been utilized to fund the major organizing speculations inside the franc zone, with the point of expanding the beneficial base so as to rise above the perilous essential mono-specialization which despite everything wins in the economies of the franc zone (Folarin, 2020).
Thus, the above responses answer the second research hypothesis which states that ‘’Togo’s economic development lays outside the franc zone’’. The research answers to this hypothesis on the basis that Togo’s economic development lays out of the franc zone but together with other franc zone countries.
Based on this analysis above, the second proposition which states that Togo’s economic development lies out of the franc zone has been justified.
4.3.3 Analysis of Proposition 3
There are possible alternatives to the franc CFA
The release of monetary speech in Africa Franc Zone, following the announcement on December 21, 2019 in Abidjan (Ivory Coast) of the imminent end of the franc CFA and its replacement by the Eco, gives rise to all possible excesses and imaginable, especially from the “fighters of the 25th hour”, who are discovering today that the franc CFA is not a currency compatible with the emergence of French-speaking Africa. But if it is important to continue to put pressure on the CFA franc, it is also essential to propose the possible contours of the transition to the replacement currency, the Eco, whose (re) birth was announced on June 29 2019 in Abuja (Nigeria) by the Summit of Heads of State and Government of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS). In this regard, four options among others seem to hold water to marry the 15 Member States invited to the Eco banquet (Massimo &Nubukpo, 2020) (Nubukpo K. , Eco et franc CFA : quatremariages et un enterrement, 2020).
- The Eco, a simple avatar of the franc CFA
This plan, which appears to have roused the Abidjan announcements of December 21, 2019, depends on consistence with ostensible union standards and a solid fascination for a fixed swapping scale system with the euro. It is wagering on the progressive development of the West African Economic and Monetary Union (UEMOA) to incorporate ECOWAS economies with indistinguishable profile of rural item exporters from those of its individuals. In this alternative, the centralization of unfamiliar trade holds is fundamental, and this is the principle accomplishment throughout the entire existence of the franc CFA. It surmises extraordinary political solidarity between Member States and it ought not to be overlooked in case of the extension of the money related zone. In like manner, the subject of the outside assurance, for example, France practices in the institutional setting of the franc CFA, has a solid political measurement: it is the premise of the solidness of the framework in principle and practically speaking. In the event that we keep the guideline of centralization of stores, however pulling together their administration in another institutional system, financial power goes from France to UEMOA and afterward to ECOWAS. There is additionally the topic of equality: a couple of years back it was the subject of significant work to propose an adaptable trade framework, or better, customizable, on the grounds that it depends on a list determined from a bin of monetary forms. The declaration made in Abidjan to keep up a fixed swapping scale with the euro on a momentary premise is the genuine staying point between the advocates of an adaptable cash (ECOWAS) and those of an Eco-CFA (Côte d ‘ Ivory and Senegal) (Folarin,2020).
- An Eco based on real convergence, that of GDP/capita
In this case, the EC economies would have the obligation to converge on the top three of Cape Verde, Nigeria and Ghana. The eco would have a flexible exchange rate regime framed by inflation targeting. The convergence dynamic would then be quite different and the WAEMU States would lose their status as good students of convergence, and therefore tractors of the eco implementation process. But Nigeria, a real heavyweight for ECOWAS (70% of GDP and52% of the population), is it ready to take on a role as a locomotive in the eco zone? Why would he agree to be the lender of last resort for ECOWAS, a role he did not want to play during the establishment of the second West African monetary zone (WAMZ) in 2002, and especially to abandon its currency, the naira, in a current context marked by the use of the printing press to resolve internal tensions in the Nigerian federation?(Amah, 2020)
· The eco-naira
For this situation, the EC economies would have the commitment to meet on the best three of Cape Verde, Nigeria and Ghana. The eco would have an adaptable swapping scale system confined by expansion focusing on. The union dynamic would then be very unique and the WAEMU States would lose their status as great understudies of union, and in these manner farm haulers of the eco execution process. In any case, Nigeria, a genuine heavyweight for ECOWAS (70% of GDP and 52% of the populace), is it prepared to take on a job as a train in the eco zone? For what reason would he consent to be the loan specialist after all other options have run out for ECOWAS, a job he would not like to play during the foundation of the second West African money related zone (WAMZ) in 2002, and particularly to surrender its cash, the naira, in a current setting set apart by the utilization of the print machine to determine inner pressures in the Nigerian federation? (Amah, 2020)
We would return here to the underlying way of thinking of the WAMZ. To be sure, on April 20, 2000 in Accra (Ghana), six West African nations (Gambia, Ghana, Guinea, Liberia, Nigeria, Sierra Leone) reported their goal to make a second fiscal zone in West Africa with as eco cash, close to the franc CFA of UEMOA. The task required an ensuing merger of these two zones, so as to cause the outskirts of the Monetary Union to concur with those of ECOWAS. In April 2002, the West African Monetary Zone (WAMZ) was set up, and every nation swore to keep its swapping scale inside a 15% variance band against the dollar.
From that point forward, dormancy has been substantial, with respect to the foundation of the single cash, before the ECOWAS Summit of June 29, 2019 in Abuja reporting the creation in 2020 of the eco and the official statement from the Council of Ministers of the WAMZ of January 16, blaming the UEMOA states for disregarding the soul of the eco money following the Abidjan assertion. This could prompt the formation of an "eco-naira", under the authority of a Nigeria stung by the French-talking activity of an "eco-CFA" during the time spent being realized (Folarin, 2020).
· The eco, a common and not a single currency
It would be a “lighter” bargain than solitary cash. This thought, the initial phase in a procedure of combination between nations, was proposed in 1960 by the Senegalese financial specialist Daniel Cabou, who might later turn into the principal secretary general of the BCEAO. The proposition, taken up nine years after the fact by Egyptian financial expert Samir Amin in a report to Nigerien President Amany Diori, was eventually deserted.
It could re-emerge today, if nations that are not yet in a situation to join the single cash tie themselves to it through conversion scale understandings. The even assimilation instruments of exchange balance awkward nature could help to re-flow surpluses inside the ECOWAS zone, by empowering specialization forms between economies which are the premise of an expansion in intra-zone exchange which turn is one of the major financial and political targets of the combination procedure. At long last, a few alternatives are on the table of West African chiefs. The way toward making the eco gives off an impression of being a genuine trial of the believability of West African vision and administration. For France, this procedure would prefer to be a trial of earnestness of its longing to really cover the CFA franc. A Togolese precept says: “when somebody professes to pass on, claim to cover them”. We should arrange the memorial service of the CFA franc and, at the hour of its entombment, in other words when the eco is really made, we will record the passing of the previous franc of the French settlements in Africa. If not, he will move and the battle will continue!
Thus, the responses above answer to the third hypothesis which states that ‘’There are possible alternatives to the franc CFA’’. This study explores various alternatives to the franc CFA and points out those ones that are for the emergence of the franc zone countries.
Based on the above analysis, this third proposition has been justified.
4.4 Summary of Findings
Money as a medium of exchange is the most powerful tool in international trade and commerce. It is also very crucial in any economy. The franc CFA which is spent in WAEMU countries is not even printed in Africa, it is produced under the auspices of France, in term regulation and determination of the value of this currency. France enjoys this because it ties this region to the apron spring of France, it gives a lot of value to french financial power so much that whenever there is a transaction between France and these countries, and France will always be at the advantage end. If we look at it critically, we will understand that it gives France leverage in terms of Purchasing Power on the level of international trade. On the level of living of French people in these countries get a very cheap cost of living, they can acquirer so much with some few Euros. So whether at the governmental or nongovernmental level, France is always winning in any trade or commerce it has with this party or even in standard of living. So Togo cannot be looked at in isolation because it is part of the entire configuration of French power and presence in Africa and also is at the receiving end of whatever France is propagating. The irony of it all is that while France is still making these countries to spend franc, France itself abandoned its currency many years ago. Even when France was still spending the franc; its franc was still not equivalent to the franc CFA. So the point is that looking at it from various angles, this is always at the advantage of France and at the detriment of these African countries having the franc CFA as currency. The impact of this is that not only it has exacerbated trade imbalances but also has created and institutionalised a master-servant relationship. Togo is a country that belongs to an economic union, however it does foreign trade with other countries; the CFA franc has numbers of measurement that do not allow the economy to develop in terms of investment. Investment facilitates production and job creation; because employment is also a criterion of economic development. Now if we consider the foreign exchange, it is difficult for Togo to be competitive in the market because it cannot meet the external debts and even to be able to vary the price of goods. We must not forget the fact that there is a fixed parity between the CFA franc and the Euro and this parity makes Togo not easily cope with inflation.
Speaking of economic development, the country itself must ensure endogenous growth. Does the franc zone promote the reduction of public debts, the unemployment rate; allow the export rate to increase: no! It is inflation that is pretty much under control. Togo has a trade deficit; trade between the countries of the franc zone is inconsiderable. This situation does not ensure intergenerational equity.
For these Franc Zone countries’ economies to improve there must be a regime change, the administrations that have the stamp of France should be gotten rid of, not by a coup but by voting them out. Let us get rid of these individuals who are stooges of colonial powers. France is very strategic, its stooges are in important countries in francophone countries in West Africa (Senegal, Cote d’Ivoire, and Togo) in Central Africa (Gabon, Chad, Cameroon, Congo). Until these countries set themselves free from the franc CFA, they would remain enslaved economically. They must set themselves free from the CFA; it is what the West is using to hold them permanently. They must have an independent central bank, and they must put their own money together and they should do it individually and if they want to do it collectively, France should not have a stamp on it.
Regional integration in the name of ECOWAS has been playing a catalyst role in the economic development of its member countries; we have the ECOWAS protocol of free movement of persons, an attempt to bring about West African Economic integration, the reduction in customs barriers, however if these countries are still attached to the aprons of former colonial powers, it is difficult to set ourselves free, it is impossible to be economically independent. The fact is that these former colonial powers would still continue to determine what we do. ECOWAS is leading with ideological and political cleavages. The ECO would have been a good initiative if it’s not having a political masquerade under which is a French face.
Togo must have its own currency; the countries of the franc zone do not have control over their exchange policy and thus suffer the consequences of fluctuations in the euro. Togolese export earnings must be converted into Euros before being converted into CFA franc, which means that when the conversion of the euro and foreign currencies fluctuate, therefore Togo's revenue also fluctuates, thus the CFA franc being a instrument of perpetuation of the colonial game, Togo would have to have its own currency, its own exchange policy, its own policy of administering its own currency, and have a flexible exchange rate to be able to allow Togolese exports to have enough value abroad and can boost economic growth in Togo.
Countries that embark on protectionism are super powers; Togo in the West African region is dependent on Ghana, Nigeria and other neighboring countries and cannot adopt protectionist policies in order to attain an economic development. Togo can only attain this latter in a regional integration. The CFA franc is a currency which deserves to be replaced; it is based on measures of the BCEAO which do not allow creating companies and a business climate in the countries which use it. For there to be development, there must be investment, whereas it is a currency that does not allow investment for employment to be created. Rather, it encourages embezzlement of public funds.
References
Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. (2012). Why nations fail. New York: Crown.
Agboli, C. (2015). Pourquoi un débat scientifique sur le franc CFA est-il tabou? .Retrieved from www.lemonde.fr: http://www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2015/06/04/pourquoi-un-debat-scientifique-sur-le-franc-cfa-est-iltabou_4647272_3212.html#pJijBxjy7kOIwFUH.99
Aghion, P., Cohen, E., & Pisani-Ferry, J. (2006). Politique économique et croissance en Europe. Conseil d’analyse économique. Paris: La Documentation francaise.
Akhalbey, F. (2019). Kwame Nkrumah’s iconic 1963 speech on African unity.(History, Ed.) Retrieved from www.face2faceafrica.com: https://face2faceafrica.com/article/read-kwame-nkrumahs-iconic-1963-speech-on-african-unity
Amah, J. (2020, March 15). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo. (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Amin, S., & Aloysius, A. (2000). Long Term Growth in the CFA franc Zone Countries . World Institute for Development Economics Research .
Banque de France. (2013). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015 ). Rapport annuel de la zone franc, Annex 1 and 2. Eurosystème .
BCEAO. (2014). Rapport annuel de la Commission Bancaire. Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.
BEAC . (2007). Convention de Compte d’Opérations de la Banque des Etats d’Afrique Centrale .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politiqque monétaire .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politique monétaire .
Bearce, D. H. (2010). Monetary divergence : Domestic policy autonomy in the Post-Bretton Woods Era . Michigan Studies in International Political Autonomy .
Bebchuk, L., & Fried, J. (2004). The managerial power perspective. In L. Bebchuk, & J. Fried, Pay without performance : the unfulfilled promise of executive compensation . Cambridge: Havard University Press .
Broz, J. L., & Jeffry, A. F. (2001). The Political Economy of International Monetary Relations. Annual Review Political Science , 317-343.
Bryman, A. (2012). Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
Burda, M., & Wyplosz, C. (2013). Macroeconomics : a European text. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Calvo, G., & Coricelli, F. (1993). Output collapse in Eastern Europe : the role of credit. IMF Staff Papers, 40 (1), 32-52.
Carlos, L. (2016, October 3). Entretien de Carlos Lopes sur RFI.Retrieved from http://www.rfi.fr: http://www.rfi.fr/emission/20161003-afrique-carloslopes-onu-franc-cfa-economie-monnaies-zone-franc-royaume-uni-ue
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique, 66, 42-55.
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique (66), 42-55.
Central Intelligence Agency. (1994). Africa Review, Special Issue : Impact of CFA Devaluation in Francophone Africa. Directorate of Intelligence .
Cessou, S. (2015). Un ministre a-t-il le droit de dire tout le mal qu’il pense du franc CFA?Retrieved from http://rue89.nouvelobs.com: http://rue89.nouvelobs.com/blog/ruesdafriques/2015/05/14/un-ministre-t-il-le-droit-de-dire-tout-le-mal-quil-pense-du-franc-cfa-234557
Claude, K. T. (2020, March 19). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Clément, J. (1996). Aftermath of the CFA Franc Devaluation . The International Monetary .
Combey, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2010). Les effets non linéaires de l’infliation sur la croissance dans l’UEMOA. Communication au Symposium de l’Institut monétaire de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (IMAO).Accra.
Cooper, F. (2002). Africa since 1940 : The Past of the Present. Cambridge : Cambrigde University Press.
Cooper, F. (2015). L’Afrique dans le monde : Capitalisme, empire, Etat-nation.Paris: Payot.
Couharde, C., Coulibaly, I., & Damette, O. (2011). Misalignments and dynamics of real exchange rates in the CFA franc zone. EconomiX, Working Papers.
Daly, J. (2014). Counterterrorism or Neo-Colonialism? The French Army in Africa. Retrieved from jamestown.org: https://jamestown.org/program/counterterrorism-or-neo-colonialism-the-french-army-in-africa/
Dembélé, D. M. (2011). Table ronde sur le Franc CFA : Que faire de la zone économique et monétaire du franc CFA, la Zone Franc : Instrument de controle et frein au développement des économies Africaines . SciencePo Paris .
Dieng, C. (2015). Idriss Deby appelle les pays africains à se débarrasser du Franc CFA.Retrieved from Afrik.com: http://www.afrik.com/idriss-deby-appelle-les-pays-africains-a-se-debarrasser-du-franccfa#YJ08iWjLKAEZcdJu.99
Folarin, S. (2020, February 26). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Frank, A. G. (1981). Reflections on the World Economics Crisis. Fund .
Frank, A. G. (1966). The Developement of Underdevelopment. London: Arnold .
Frey, L., Botan, C., & Kreps, G. (1999). Investigating communication : An introduction to research methods. Boston & Bacon: Allyn & Bacon.
George, A. L., & Bennett, A. (2005). Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. MIT Press .
Gill, S. (1993). Gramsci, Historical Materialism and Inteernational Relations . Cambrigde University Press .
Graeber, D. (2013). Dette, 5000 ans d’histoire. Paris: Les Liens qui libèrent.
Griffin, C. (2007). French Military Interventions in Africa : Realism vs. Ideology in French Defense Policy and Grand Strategy . International Studies Association .
Gulde, A.-M. (2008). The CFA Franc Zone : Common Currency, Uncommon Challenges. International Monetary Fund Books .
Hallet, M. (n.d.). The role of the euro in Sub-Saharan Africa and in the CFA franc zone. Economic and Financial Affairs, European Commission, Economic , 347.
Ibid. (2000). L’analyse des deux vagues de politiques monétaires restrictives en Russie de 1993 à 1999.
Ibrahima Jr, D. (2020, February 1). A Dakar, Kako Nubukpo appelle l’Afrique à rompre avec la “croissance sans développement”.Retrieved from https://www.financialafrik.com: https://www.financialafrik.com/2020/02/01/a-dakar-kako-nubukpo-appelle-lafrique-a-rompre-avec-la-croissance-sans-developpement/
Kaldor, M. (2007). Oil and Conflict. London: Pluto Press.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
La France et l’outre-mer : un siècle de relations monétaires et financières. (1996). Actes du colloque tenu à Bercy (p. 695). Bercy: Comité pour l’histoire économique et financière de la France.
Lelart, M. (2003). L’Union monétaire en Afrique de l’Ouest. L’Economie politique , 19 (3), 106-112.
Massimo, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2020, Mars). Una nuova moneta per gli Stati dell’Ovest. Le condizioni teoriche e politiche della sua fattibilita. Moneta e Credito .
Mbaye, A. A., & Mballa, C. (2019). La zone Franc d’hier à aujourd’ui. Interventions économques : Papers i,n Political economy .
Mborg, R. (2015). Le franc CFA freine le développement de l’Afriqque. Le Monde .
McMichael, P. (2011). Development and Social Change : A Global Perspective . SAGE Publications .
Messanh, N. L. (2017, March 13). Le Togolais Kako Nubukpo primé pour son ouvrage « L’envol de l’Epervier : le défi de l’émergence togolaise ».Retrieved August 4, 2020, from financialafrik: https://www.financialafrik.com/2017/03/13/le-togolais-kako-nubukpo-prime-pour-son-ouvrage-lenvol-de-lepervier-le-defi-de-lemergence-togolaise/
Minart, G. (2016). Jaquier Rueff : Un liberal francais.Paris: Odile Jacob.
Mundell, R. (1961). A theory of optimum currency areas. American Economic Review (4).
Ndongo, S. S. (2017, July 12). Firoz Lalji Centre for Africa. Retrieved July 27, 2020, from https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/africaatlse/2017/07/12/the-cfa-franc-french-monetary-imperialism-in-africa/
Nkrumah, K. (1965). Neo-Colonialism, the Last Stage of imperialism.
Nubukpo, K. (2020, January 21). Eco et franc CFA : quatre mariages et un enterrement.Retrieved January 29, 2020, from www.jeuneafrique.com: https://www.jeuneafrique.com/884260/economie/tribune-eco-et-franc-cfa-quatre-mariages-et-un-enterrement/
Nubukpo, K. (2016). Le Franc CFA et le financement de l’émergence en zone franc . 123-133.
Nubukpo, K. (2011). L’improvisation économique en Afrique de l’Ouest – Du Cotton au Francc CFA. Paris : Khartala.
Nubukpo, K. (2019). L’Urgence africaine : Changeons le modèle de croissance ! Paris: Odile Jacob.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : La gestion du franc CFA par la BCEAO. Politique africaine, 105, 70-82.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : la gestion du franc CFA par la BECEAO. Politique africaine (105), 70-82.
Nubukpo, K., & Deh, C. P. (2016). L’envol de l’épervier : le défi de l’émergence Togolaise. Lomé: Graines de Pensées.
Nubukpo, K., Belinga, M., & Dembélé, D. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la sevitude monétaire. Paris, France: La dispute.
Nubupko, K., Belinga, M. Z., Tinel, B., & Dembélé, D. M. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la servitude monétaire : A qui profite le franc CFA ?Paris: La Dispute.
Oatley, T., & Kindred, W. (2014). Handbook of the international political economy of monetary relations. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
O’Brien, R., & Williams, M. (2013). Global political economy. Palgrave Macmillan.
Ould-Ahmed, P. (1999). Politiques monétaires, comportements bancaires et crises de financement en Russie : les vicissitudes des années 1990. Revue d’études comparatives Est-Ouest,, 30 (2-3), 89-121.
Pape, L. D. (1998). L’impact des taux directeurs de la BCEAO sur les taux débiteurs des banques . Notes d’Information et Statistiques , 483-484.
Pigeaud, F. (2016). Une monnaie nocive pour les Etats africains. Médiapart .
Polzer, T. (2001). Corruption : Deconstructing the World Bank Discourse. Development Studies Institute, London School of Economics, Working Paper Series, 1470 (2320).
Profant, T. (2010). French Geopolitics in Africa : From Neo-colonialism to Identity. Perspectives, 18 (1).
Saint-Légier, R. (1956). La zone franc, mécanismes, problèmes internationaux. Annuaire francaise de droit international, 2 (1956), 260-27.
Shatz, H. J., & Tarr, D. (2000). Exchange Rate Overvaluation and Trade Protection : Lessons from Experience . The World Bank .
Shillington, K. (2005). History of Africa. Macmillian Publishers Limited.
Smith, N. (2013). What is ”neoclassical” economics?
Strange, S. (1988). States and markets. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Todaro, M., & Smith, S. (2015). Economic development. Harlow: Pearson.
Trésor Direction Générale. (2013). 40 ans d’histoire de la Zone franc – Principes et modalités de fonctionnement de la coopération monétaire. Paris: Ministère de l’économie, République Francaise .
UEMOA. (1973). Traité du 14 novembre 1973 constituant l’Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.Préambule.
United Nations Development Programme. (1997). Human Development Report . Oxford University Press.
United Nations. (2006). Human Development Report. Beyond scarcity: Power, poverty and the global water crisis. United Nations Development Programme. Palgrave Macmillan.
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Credit policy, inflation and growth in a financially repressed economy. Journal of Development Economics, (13).
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Interest rate management in LDC. Journal of Monetary Economics, 12 (12).
World Bank. (2017). GDP per capita growth (annual%). The World Bank Group.
CHAPTER 5
SUMMARY, RECOMMENDATION AND CONCLUSION
5.1 Introduction
This chapter accentuates the summary, recommendations and conclusion of this research work.
5.2 Summary
This research work has investigated the impact of the franc CFA on franc zone countries with Togo as a case study. The objective was to explore the entire system behind the franc CFA, what it represents to France who initiated it and franc zone countries who are using it. Is the franc CFA monetary policies favoring or affecting the economic development of these countries? Are we in a case of monetary dependency? How has this entire system affecting the lives of so many Africans in these countries? These are some of the questions we tried to buttress with primary and secondary data.
The study consists of five (5) chapters which include:
Chapter one presenting a general introduction on the subject and the plans of the study; the chapter two talks about various concepts in line with the study and the theory that suits the study. The chapter three discusses the research methodology engaged in this work. It elaborates on the research design, population study, and sample size, instruments of data collection, validity and reliability of instrument as well as method of analysis. It further proceeds in laying down the study issues. Chapter four emphasizes the presentation of data, analysis of data, summary and discussion of findings.
5.3 Recommendations
In the light of the above, we understand the arguments of the opponents of the CFA franc and the franc zone who maintain that these represent a mortgage on the economic development and social progress of African countries. The experience of the greater part a century has demonstrated that the “assets” which they were supposed to represent for the latter were rather mirages, which weighed down the potentialities they had at the beginning of their independence. In the light of the above, we understand the arguments of the opponents of the CFA franc and the franc zone who maintain that these represent a mortgage on the economic development and social progress of African countries.
Do not take the euro as a model
The situation of African countries was not taken into account in any way when pegging the CFA franc to the euro. Responding to this aberration by building a new form of African monetary union supposes not replicating the technical and political modalities of European Economic and Monetary Union. There are two motivations to accept that this method would not be the right one. The first was recalled previously: Africa’s economic, social and political characteristics are very different from those of the European Union. The second relates to the very goals of these two experiences of monetary integration. The search for a new monetary organization for sub-Saharan Africa only makes sense if it helps liberate the populations of these regions from the economic and political dominions inherited from colonialism and deepened under the empire of financial globalization which governs the world economy for thirty-five years. However, the form of monetary cooperation that constitutes the euro is also the instrument of various dominions: domination of financial criteria over economic policy decisions and over the management of companies in the euro zone; but also the domination of German capital within the Monetary Union; US monetary and financial domination over the euro area by virtue of the dollar privilege, which serves as the basis of the international monetary system as it currently functions; and, more specifically, the continuation in another form of the domination of the franc over the former colonies of West and Central Africa.
Distinguishing these four levels of domination makes it possible to identify different aspects according to which African monetary cooperation should be distinguished from the current European monetary construction.
Create money for jobs and development, not for profitability and finance
Starting a recovery and then taking off for a long time will require breaking free from the subtle and complex mechanisms that restrict “credit” in all the economies of the franc zone. With this reservation, we can recognize that another issue of currency articulated around a new exchange rate regime would offer in the short term the breaths of fresh air that most countries in the zone lack and would give politicians room for manoeuvre. development public. Thus, the demand for a relaxation of the obligation to cover the issue and a more flexible but controlled exchange rate is betting that these provisions would have a favourable impact on growth, but which, given the narrow domestic market would increase inflation. This scenario remains very hypothetical, however. Indeed, several sub-Saharan countries both in the east and in the west (Nigeria, Ghana, Angola, Botswana) have experimented with other exchange rate regimes (dollarization, flexible anchoring to the rand) without being able to find any relationship between exchange rate regimes and observed growth trends. The pre-eminence of the defence of the exchange rate (and its associated corollaries, convertibility and transferability) obliges central banks to constitute foreign exchange reserves with the French Treasury, in excessive proportions with regard to the guarantee strictly necessary for the monetary issue. The tables below describe the close relationship between the constitution of foreign exchange reserves and the issuance of money in the two currency subzones, resulting in an artificial rationing of credit.
As required by the conventions revised in 2005, the central banks of the two zones must constitute foreign currency reserves stored in their operations account with the ‘’Banque de France’’ at a minimum level of 20% of their issues.
We can therefore consider that a potential for money creation is underutilized in the franc zone, or that it is misused. What if such amounts were actually made available to these savings? Would they not end up fleeing economic circuits, to escape via imports or via capital flight in the absence of self-centred growth and a consolidated domestic market? Both real and monetary extraversion remains a major obstacle. A first condition to remedy this would be to introduce more flexible management of the exchange rate.
More importantly, it would be essential to change the criteria for using the power of monetary creation available to the European Central Bank and which would have its equivalent in an African monetary union. Rather than subjecting the management of economies to the criteria of financial profitability in force in international capital markets, criteria more appropriate for the success of an autonomous development strategy should be given priority. These criteria have an economic aspect: creation of added value in the territories, establishment of an autonomous research and development capacity. They have a social aspect: job creation, worker training, wage increases in a process of increasing productivity and reducing inequalities. Finally, they have an ecological aspect: installation of the equipment necessary for the controlled exploitation of natural resources, the protection of the environment and the development of renewable energies to meet the needs that are expected to grow with economic development, while reducing the use of fossil fuels. The monetary policy of an African central bank should therefore be selective so that the liquidity made available to the banking system serves as the basis for the extension of long-term loans and at low interest rates to finance investments meeting these criteria.
The shallowness of what Marx called the “credit system” in the economies of the present franc zone may appear to be a limit to the implementation of such a monetary strategy; it can also be an opportunity to base the future development of these economies on bases that are different from what the domination of financial markets imposes on developed economies today.
It would then remain to verify whether the monetary and financial system is sending the right signals. In fact, a cartelized banking system (under French domination) succeeds for the moment in maintaining the situational rents by favouring the financing of multinational firms (MNCs) and other large accounts to the detriment of SMEs and small farms, or even the purchase of government securities (the debt market, taking into account spreads) rather than the financing of long-cycle projects.
However, putting financial resources and monetary creation at the service of a development strategy that meets the aspirations of the people cannot be done only by decree: it is a question of opposing the criteria of financial profitability which weigh in all decisions decentralized systems governing private and public investments and their financing, with all the power given to them by the financial markets. So we need democratic, decentralized powers of citizens over the use of money. It would be up to the African peoples and the leaders they would choose to determine what lessons to draw, for the specific case of Africa, from the avenues explored in this direction by the democratic movement elsewhere in the world: direct access of citizens to information detailed on the action of banks in the territories, on the model of the American Community Reinvestment Act, new rights for employees on their companies’ access to bank financing, application of the principles of the social and solidarity economy to the usage mutual banking networks, public actions on the behaviour of banks through the development of public financial centres and through the use of economic intervention tools such as interest rate subsidies or loan guarantees, etc. In the specific case of Africa, we can think that special attention should be paid to microcredit practices and their articulation with the financial system as a whole. On the other hand, mastering the local activity of multinational banks can be of strategic importance in countries where their presence has often preceded the development of a national banking system.
A monetary community to reduce disparities between regions and between States
The second aspect which makes the euro an instrument of domination expresses the economic heterogeneity of the euro zone, marked by the growing weight of Germany and by a gap between a Northern Europe anchored to Germanic power and a Southern Europe financially dependent because of a lower efficiency of its productive base, and threatened, depending on the circumstances, with marginalization or even exclusion. The uniqueness and uniformity of European monetary policy materialized by the independence of the Central Bank, ostensibly inspired by the Deutsche Bundes bank, have in fact contributed to reinforcing the polarization of the economic space within the euro zone and to strengthen German hegemony; but Monetary Union itself found itself vulnerable when it appeared that, contrary to the postulate of the Treaties, the expulsion of a member of the euro area, in this case Greece was not inconceivable. A progressive response to the initial power disparities within a monetary cooperation area should not aim to impose on the area as a whole the policies preferred by the most powerful state, as is the case today or to institutionalize a “transfer union” in which the nationals of the most competitive countries in international trade would pay eternally to preserve the standard of living of the inhabitants of “poor” countries, as well as the most German reactionaries affect to fear him. The control of the currency, by a central bank at the service of the people and not of the financial markets, would allow a monetization of the payment deficits within the zone, but with as counterpart the use of this monetary creation for the financing of investments leading to economic and social efficiency, in order to create the conditions for the convergence of economies towards a system aimed at the best development of human capacities. This would be particularly necessary in the case of sub-Saharan Africa, which, even less than the euro area, does not constitute, as Kako Nubukpo points out, an “optimal currency area”.
There would be there a concrete solidarity between countries within the monetary zone, which supposes an organization of the capacity radically different from that which is currently in force in the euro zone. Rather than a single and uniform monetary policy over the whole of the zone, one can imagine that it would be advisable to define forms of cooperation making possible a monetary regime susceptible to differentiations of a country or a region to another depending on employment development needs and added value. In the European case, before the Maastricht Treaty, communist economists had proposed the creation of a common currency of cooperation, put into circulation in addition to national currencies, as an alternative to the single currency. A quarter of a century more Later, a proposal responding to the same concerns could consist in strengthening, within the Euro system, the scope for autonomous action of national central banks. In fact, the realities of the euro crisis have given rise to mechanisms of this nature. Thus, in November 2011, the Governing Council of the ECB authorized the national central banks to propose the inclusion of certain types of assets as collateral for Euro system loans to commercial banks. Another example is paradoxically provided by the special regime to which the central currency supply of Greek banks has been subject since February 2015, following the constitution of the Syriza government: these, short of liquidity due to the flight of deposits of their customers, may not obtain Euros from the Euro system through its ordinary refinancing operations associated since March 2016 at a rate of 0%. However, they can obtain it from the Bank of Greece as “Emergency Liquidity Assistance” (“ELA”), at the penalizing rate of 1.55% and for a fixed amount, day after day, by the Governing Council of the ECB. Although it uses this institutional device for punitive ends in order to keep the Greek economy dependent on the “troika”, the ECB nonetheless demonstrates, reluctantly, that the principle of differentiation monetary policies from one country to another is indeed part of the rules compatible with Economic and Monetary Union, and that it could therefore be used for a purpose quite opposite to that of the austerity policies currently in force.
Cooperate in Africa to change the international monetary system.
The third characteristic aspect of the current European monetary construction is its insertion into a financial globalization dominated by American capital. One of the effects of the neoliberal reforms launched from the end of the 1970s was to restore American monetary hegemony shaken by the fall of the Bretton Woods system and by the relinquishment of the convertibility of the dollar into gold from 1971. This strategy succeeded, and it inaugurated a functioning of Western economies favourable to an increased levy of capital on the wealth produced; but, by reducing spending on wages and training, it weakened both demand and the productive potential of developed economies. The gigantic expansion of financial markets has also provoked increasingly violent financial crises, opening up a crisis in the current international monetary order. The emerging countries are now openly contesting the place of the dollar as a de facto global common currency and universal reference for the international monetary system. Logically at the forefront of this movement, China, through the voice of the governor of its central bank, has gone so far as to advocate the replacement of the dollar as an international reserve instrument by a new instrument developed from the special drawing rights of the IMF. This idea echoes the ideas defended by Keynes at the Bretton Woods conference.
It is very precisely in line with the proposition formulated in 1983 by the French Marxist economist Paul Boccara9 who advocated transforming the SDRs into a common global currency issued by an International Monetary Fund radically transformed in its objectives and in its “governance”. The basic use of such globally regulated monetary creation would be to develop long-term loans at very low interest rates to finance investments democratically selected on the basis of social criteria (job creation, training ), economic (creation of added value in the territories) and ecological (saving energy and raw materials). Sub-Saharan Africa is primarily concerned by these objectives, to which its own monetary organization must be able to contribute. For example, the project to peg future African currencies to a basket of currencies including the euro, the dollar and the renminbi can be seen as a step in the direction of the construction of this new international order. In contrast, the euro is seen as an obstacle. It is in fact in a world dominated by the “exorbitant privilege” of the dollar that the project of Economic and Monetary Union was registered, sanctioned by the ratification of the Maastricht Treaty in 1992. The objective was to include the euro zone by making it a place of attraction for financial capital in the geography of financial globalization with the development, in Frankfurt or Paris, of competing financial centres of New York, Tokyo or Singapore. Yet in debates over solutions to the dollar crisis, European authorities have consistently sided with the status quo. This pusillanimity goes against the interests of peoples, both south and north of the Mediterranean. The conquest by the African peoples of monetary sovereignty is part of both the development project of the area and the search for a new international monetary order, a determining element of which would be the invention of a new relationship between Africa and Europe.
A new monetary cooperation between Africa and Europe
The modalities of further cooperation between Europe and its neighbours to the south of the Mediterranean remain to be defined. The overall rationale is to select projects that generate wealth creation in Africa by sharing the costs of the necessary investments and by allocating Euros created by the ECB to finance these investments. Precautions should be taken so that the definition of these projects and the financial benefits that would be derived from them are not the sole responsibility of European entities - States, community institutions and private companies -, but that the peoples - and not only African states are in control. The ECB could selectively refinance loans granted by African or international financial institutions (such as a World Bank profoundly transformed in its objectives as well as in its "governance"). She could also enter into agreements with African central banks to provide them with reserves in Euros intended to finance development projects. This would be a form of cooperation that is both more intimate (because it is based on a concerted selection of concrete projects) and more balanced than the current dependence of the franc zone on the French Treasury and on ECB policy.
In the hierarchical system of relations and dominations that characterize capitalist globalization, Africa and the euro zone occupy very different positions.
In both cases, however, it is possible to define fairly precisely what institutional changes would be necessary to break free from dependence on multinational strategies and on investment and funding criteria dictated by financial markets. There is a coherence there which can favour a convergence in the social and political struggles which aim to achieve these common objectives.
5.4 Conclusion
The fruit is ripe and needs to be picked.
The franc CFA, as a colonial survival, is, among other elements, one of the instruments of maintenance in place of “above-ground” regimes, as if suspended from the old metropolis above their people. It allows wealthy elites to enjoy privileged access to the world market through a currency “as good” as the euro without the CFA, importing the goods that the ACFZ ruling classes need for their own consumption and to maintain dominance would be prohibitively expensive. The elites of these countries can also value their fortune in Euros very quickly and without currency risk. This postcolonial currency thus contributes to maintaining the abyssal differences of wealth and power between ordinary people and the ruling classes. Because the dominant classes in these countries are much favoured by the CFA system compared to the vast majority of the population, they are thus structurally dependent on the former metropolis, which partly explains the persistence of this system, nearly sixty years after independence. But why would these leaders act against their own interests? We understand the reasons for their passivity just as much as we blame their egoism, for these same classes were quick to incriminate “France” regularly in an attempt to cover their tracks by playing on identity strings, in an effort to reconnect with the populations that, moreover, they crush and, thus, try not to have to account for their acts in front of the public opinions of their own countries and sub-regions. The stake is, therefore, democratic. But this story is nothing more than that of cooperation: the elites on both sides find common ground, because the CFA also directly serves the economic interests of French and European multinational companies operating in the territories of the ACFZ by securing their profits in a currency as good as the euro. He also directly serves the people attached to the French bureaucracies and the ACFZ in charge of its administration, quite simply because it is their job to administer the CFA although few in number, these actors are influential by their interstitial position. The ACFZ thus constitute a private preserve for the economic and administrative interests of the former colonizer. In return, it provides the ruling classes of these countries with the means to stay in power and lead a comfortable life, notably thanks to the CFA. The latter do well to their French equivalents because, for example, we now know that the means of financing illegal of political parties in France until recently passed through the bank accounts of their rich African counterparts.
However, such shopkeeper considerations do not exhaust the entire reality of CFA. French interests, of the “national” type, in their former colonies in Africa are now concentrated in the field of raw materials (oil, uranium, etc.) and in the geostrategic field. These territories constitute a privileged sphere of influence which gives France an international stature and allows it to maintain itself as a second-rate power, particularly on the military level. Moreover, the frequent armed interventions of France on the soil of its former colonies result in part from the fact that the CFA system helps to maintain fragile and dependent governments of the former metropolis. The CFA is certainly not, on its own the foundation of these various elements of international relations, but it helps to establish French influence in Africa. This explains why the French ruling classes are in no hurry to get rid of it, even if they probably perceive its outdated character.
Scholars on this topic believe that somehow the “CFA fruit” is ripe and therefore should be picked by those very who use it. As it were, the time has come for the franc CFA to pass into the hands of Africans. First for political reasons, as the sterling area ended in 1967, it is time for the ACFZ to gain full and complete monetary sovereignty. This question is not secondary it is no more and no less about the right of peoples to self-determination. If these countries were ultimately to alienate all or part of this portion of their sovereignty, as the member countries of the euro area did, such an option should not be imposed on them from outside but should result from an internal process. Where all points of view would be expressed freely, and without fear of reprisals, and which would thus allow sovereign peoples to clearly state their preference for such a choice. This would seal the advent of a new monetary pact and, above all, give it real internal legitimacy.
There is far to go and there is little doubt that greater political, and no doubt monetary, instability will be the price to pay for regained monetary sovereignty. Not that skills are lacking: there are already within central banks ACFZ, African international institutions, administrations and universities of each country as well as in the Diaspora, hundreds of young economists, lawyers, managers, political scientists, financiers and African managers trained and African trained at the highest level and whose capacities only ask to be employed to help manage their independent currency. In addition, it is necessary that the CFA evolve, or even disappear, for reasons of economic efficiency: this work has helped to recall how the supposed “monetary stability” provided by the current system has proved its limits. This “fixed” stability practiced within the CFA does not provide monetary conditions conducive to endogenous development to meet the needs of the ACFZ. Obviously, it isn’t the main factor; however it is one of the elements of the blockage. We are not unaware of how the road is strewn with pitfalls, in the first place because modern currencies are backed by state forms – the prince has his currency, the currency has its prince -. However, the monopoly of public violence sometimes remains fragile, so much so that the tax systems on which real investment and development programs could be based are still lacking. Thus, the partial or total abandonment of the CFA opens the field of possibilities and creates a lot of uncertainty. Both the best and the worst can result. It is not excluded that in certain cases we may witness a disintegration of state forms, and therefore a breakdown and then a reorganization of the organization of powers in certain territories. It should not be overlooked that such a process can be time consuming and most likely involves violence. Despite what might be expected, it can likewise prompt the consolidation of civil peace, because monetary sovereignty makes it possible to strengthen and legitimize current state structures by making policies more reliable by taking root democratic.
Social forces and political intelligence will decide. Such a question goes far beyond the subject of this book, which is intended to be a call both to get out of the status quo and to start thinking about monetary issues in West and Central Africa beyond the current systems. The dominant dogmas of free trade and the free movement of capital must be questioned in the context of an overall reflection on economic, social and political development. It is up to Africans to take full charge of their development and to invent the institutional forms, articulating public action and individual freedom, which suit them in order to finally provide for the basic needs of each. We must not wait patiently for the French government to reform the CFA itself in the interests of Africans: like any government, the French government primarily defends its national interests. It is therefore up to African governments and societies to take up this issue and develop one or more projects. It is up to African citizens to make the experience of cooperation and confrontation among themselves in order to develop their own institutions by themselves, especially in the monetary field. Certainly, on the French side, African monetary emancipation is not viewed favourably by all the players, but at a time when the crisis of confidence in the euro is very strong, when citizens in France and throughout Europe perceive the supranational European currency as a means of domination within Europe itself, it will be very difficult in the public debate in France to go against the desire for monetary autonomy of the African countries. On the African side, to gain such autonomy by limiting as much as possible the confrontation necessarily hazardous and costly with the “Françafrique” networks, it is important to convince the public that new forms of international relations, more balanced and based more on cooperation, will be just as beneficial to the old metropolis and will not nullify its geostrategic interests in Africa.
France has little to lose and a lot to gain from the economic development of its former colonies. But if French public opinion feels that it must cede all African ground to its great international rival-partners (China, United States, etc.), some tensions are to be expected. For this reason, reflection on monetary issues in ACFZs must now go beyond the necessary understandable and justified stage of simply rejecting the constraints imposed by the current system; Now is the time to develop new projects based on what already exists with a view to transforming it while remembering that there will be, in any case, new constraints that will have to be dealt with. This book has shown that there is unused room for manoeuvre within the current system itself which would allow for a more flexible monetary policy in West and Central Africa. As it is very difficult to create from nothing, to develop institutions, to take advantage of the achievements in terms of coordination, cooperation and expertise of ACFZs can prove to be a strategic asset in making them an economic and political entity autonomous. Thus, we also tried to demonstrate that the existing institutions could be reformed in a direction more in line with the economic interests of the ACFZs, which would in the process stop wasting the skills of central bankers, who have been occupied since decades of practicing their own monetary repression identified almost forty years ago by Joseph TchundjangPouemi and, on the contrary, of putting these talents at the service of the entire population rather than only the interests of castes and neo-colonial networks that take advantage of the current system.
Regarding external objectives, the future ex-CFA (we will have to name this new currency one day!) could be anchored in the international monetary system through a limited-flexibility exchange regime, by referring in particular to a basket of currencies whose composition and weightings would themselves be adjustable according to the requirements of international trade relations. Internally, the very notion of monetary stability could be revised and be anchored no longer on a nominal value chosen more or less arbitrarily and in a fixist manner as is currently the case but on a determined moving value of endogenous to economic activity. The future ex-CFA could merge in part into the single currency project of ECOWAS under the leadership of Nigeria; it would then remain to imagine what would become of the CEMAC zone. It would also be possible to imagine a post-CFA zone including UEMOA and CEMAC, which would limit the Nigerian hold on its neighbours, smaller and less powerful. The question of oil must also be taken seriously: oil is a poisoned gift for development, not only because it arouses greed and corruption, but also because it encourages monetary overvaluation, which does not favour agricultural and industrial development (this problem is well known as “Dutch disease”).
One could thus imagine two post-CFA zones, one made up of oil-producing countries and the other made up of countries with little or no oil. But creativity is not limited to these sketches: for example, it would be possible for certain countries currently located outside the CFA zone to join current CFA countries. New solidarities and re-compositions can be built with as much lucidity as voluntarism. Finally, it will be necessary to include the (or future) currency (s) that will succeed (or succeed) the CFA in a project not simply of growth and development, as it was four decades ago, but now in a realistic perspective of “transformation” industrial, technological, societal which will have implications for the organization of the financing system. Even if these questions, and many others, will not be resolved in a book but by the harsh reality of the balance of power, they must be thought about and discussed today so that reason and debate come to enlighten them and temper them.
Bibliography
Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. (2012). Why nations fail. New York: Crown.
Agboli, C. (2015). Pourquoi un débat scientifique sur le franc CFA est-il tabou? . Retrieved from www.lemonde.fr: http://www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2015/06/04/pourquoi-un-debat-scientifique-sur-le-franc-cfa-est-iltabou_4647272_3212.html#pJijBxjy7kOIwFUH.99
Aghion, P., Cohen, E., & Pisani-Ferry, J. (2006). Politique économique et croissance en Europe. Conseil d’analyse économique. Paris: La Documentation francaise.
Akhalbey, F. (2019). Kwame Nkrumah’s iconic 1963 speech on African unity. (History, Ed.) Retrieved from www.face2faceafrica.com: https://face2faceafrica.com/article/read-kwame-nkrumahs-iconic-1963-speech-on-african-unity
Amah, J. (2020, March 15). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo. (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Amin, S., & Aloysius, A. (2000). Long Term Growth in the CFA franc Zone Countries . World Institute for Development Economics Research .
Banque de France. (2013). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
Banque de France. (2015 ). Rapport annuel de la zone franc, Annex 1 and 2. Eurosystème .
Banque de France. (2015). La Zone Franc, Note D’information. Eurosystème.
BCEAO. (2014). Rapport annuel de la Commission Bancaire. Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine.
BEAC . (2007). Convention de Compte d’Opérations de la Banque des Etats d’Afrique Centrale .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politiqque monétaire .
BEAC. (2017). Stratégie de politique monétaire .
Bearce, D. H. (2010). Monetary divergence : Domestic policy autonomy in the Post-Bretton Woods Era . Michigan Studies in International Political Autonomy .
Bebchuk, L., & Fried, J. (2004). The managerial power perspective. In L. Bebchuk, & J. Fried, Pay without performance : the unfulfilled promise of executive compensation . Cambridge: Havard University Press .
Broz, J. L., & Jeffry, A. F. (2001). The Political Economy of International Monetary Relations. Annual Review Political Science, 317-343.
Bryman, A. (2012). Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
Burda, M., & Wyplosz, C. (2013). Macroeconomics : a European text. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Calvo, G., & Coricelli, F. (1993). Output collapse in Eastern Europe : the role of credit. IMF Staff Papers, 40(1), 32-52.
Carlos, L. (2016, October 3). Entretien de Carlos Lopes sur RFI. Retrieved from http://www.rfi.fr: http://www.rfi.fr/emission/20161003-afrique-carloslopes-onu-franc-cfa-economie-monnaies-zone-franc-royaume-uni-ue
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique, 66, 42-55.
Carré, E. (2015). Les politiques monétaires non conventionnelles de la BCE : théories et pratiques. L’Economie politique(66), 42-55.
Central Intelligence Agency. (1994). Africa Review, Special Issue : Impact of CFA Devaluation in Francophone Africa. Directorate of Intelligence.
Cessou, S. (2015). Un ministre a-t-il le droit de dire tout le mal qu’il pense du franc CFA? Retrieved from http://rue89.nouvelobs.com: http://rue89.nouvelobs.com/blog/ruesdafriques/2015/05/14/un-ministre-t-il-le-droit-de-dire-tout-le-mal-quil-pense-du-franc-cfa-234557
Claude, K. T. (2020, March 19). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Clément, J. (1996). Aftermath of the CFA Franc Devaluation . The International Monetary.
Combey, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2010). Les effets non linéaires de l’infliation sur la croissance dans l’UEMOA. Communication au Symposium de l’Institut monétaire de l’Afrique de l’Ouest (IMAO). Accra.
Cooper, F. (2002). Africa since 1940 : The Past of the Present. Cambridge : Cambrigde University Press.
Cooper, F. (2015). L’Afrique dans le monde : Capitalisme, empire, Etat-nation. Paris: Payot.
Couharde, C., Coulibaly, I., & Damette, O. (2011). Misalignments and dynamics of real exchange rates in the CFA franc zone. EconomiX, Working Papers.
Daly, J. (2014). Counterterrorism or Neo-Colonialism? The French Army in Africa. Retrieved from jamestown.org: https://jamestown.org/program/counterterrorism-or-neo-colonialism-the-french-army-in-africa/
Dembélé, D. M. (2011). Table ronde sur le Franc CFA : Que faire de la zone économique et monétaire du franc CFA, la Zone Franc : Instrument de controle et frein au développement des économies Africaines . SciencePo Paris .
Dieng, C. (2015). Idriss Deby appelle les pays africains à se débarrasser du Franc CFA. Retrieved from Afrik.com: http://www.afrik.com/idriss-deby-appelle-les-pays-africains-a-se-debarrasser-du-franccfa#YJ08iWjLKAEZcdJu.99
Folarin, S. (2020, February 26). Franc CFA and Economic Development in Franc Zone : A Study of Togo . (L. Timothew, Interviewer)
Frank, A. G. (1966). The Developement of Underdevelopment. London: Arnold .
Frank, A. G. (1981). Reflections on the World Economics Crisis. Fund.
Frey, L., Botan, C., & Kreps, G. (1999). Investigating communication : An introduction to research methods. Boston & Bacon: Allyn & Bacon.
George, A. L., & Bennett, A. (2005). Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences. MIT Press.
Gill, S. (1993). Gramsci, Historical Materialism and Inteernational Relations . Cambrigde University Press.
Graeber, D. (2013). Dette, 5000 ans d’histoire. Paris: Les Liens qui libèrent.
Griffin, C. (2007). French Military Interventions in Africa : Realism vs. Ideology in French Defense Policy and Grand Strategy . International Studies Association .
Gulde, A.-M. (2008). The CFA Franc Zone : Common Currency, Uncommon Challenges. International Monetary Fund Books.
Hallet, M. (n.d.). The role of the euro in Sub-Saharan Africa and in the CFA franc zone. Economic and Financial Affairs, European Commission, Economic, 347.
Ibid. (2000). L’analyse des deux vagues de politiques monétaires restrictives en Russie de 1993 à 1999.
Ibrahima Jr, D. (2020, February 1). A Dakar, Kako Nubukpo appelle l’Afrique à rompre avec la “croissance sans développement”. Retrieved from https://www.financialafrik.com: https://www.financialafrik.com/2020/02/01/a-dakar-kako-nubukpo-appelle-lafrique-a-rompre-avec-la-croissance-sans-developpement/
Kaldor, M. (2007). Oil and Conflict. London: Pluto Press.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
Kiema, C., Nubukpo, K., & Sanou, G. (2011). Impact d’une dévaluation du franc CFA sur la balance commerciale et la production dans les pays de l’UEMOA. Chocs dans les pays en développement. Paris: DIAL /Université Paris-Dauphine.
La France et l’outre-mer : un siècle de relations monétaires et financières. (1996). Actes du colloque tenu à Bercy (p. 695). Bercy: Comité pour l’histoire économique et financière de la France.
Lelart, M. (2003). L’Union monétaire en Afrique de l’Ouest. L’Economie politique , 19(3), 106-112.
Massimo, A., & Nubukpo, K. (2020, Mars). Una nuova moneta per gli Stati dell’Ovest. Le condizioni teoriche e politiche della sua fattibilita. Moneta e Credito.
Mbaye, A. A., & Mballa, C. (2019). La zone Franc d’hier à aujourd’ui. Interventions économques : Papers i,n Political economy.
Mborg, R. (2015). Le franc CFA freine le développement de l’Afriqque. Le Monde.
McMichael, P. (2011). Development and Social Change : A Global Perspective . SAGE Publications.
Messanh, N. L. (2017, March 13). Le Togolais Kako Nubukpo primé pour son ouvrage « L’envol de l’Epervier : le défi de l’émergence togolaise ». Retrieved August 4, 2020, from financialafrik: https://www.financialafrik.com/2017/03/13/le-togolais-kako-nubukpo-prime-pour-son-ouvrage-lenvol-de-lepervier-le-defi-de-lemergence-togolaise/
Minart, G. (2016). Jaquier Rueff : Un liberal francais. Paris: Odile Jacob.
Mundell, R. (1961). A theory of optimum currency areas. American Economic Review (4).
Ndongo, S. S. (2017, July 12). Firoz Lalji Centre for Africa. Retrieved July 27, 2020, from https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/africaatlse/2017/07/12/the-cfa-franc-french-monetary-imperialism-in-africa/
Nkrumah, K. (1965). Neo-Colonialism, the Last Stage of imperialism.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : La gestion du franc CFA par la BCEAO. Politique africaine, 105, 70-82.
Nubukpo, K. (2007). Politique monétaire et servitude volontaire : la gestion du franc CFA par la BECEAO. Politique africaine(105), 70-82.
Nubukpo, K. (2011). L’improvisation économique en Afrique de l’Ouest – Du Cotton au Francc CFA. Paris : Khartala.
Nubukpo, K. (2016). Le Franc CFA et le financement de l’émergence en zone franc . 123-133.
Nubukpo, K. (2019). L’Urgence africaine : Changeons le modèle de croissance ! Paris: Odile Jacob.
Nubukpo, K. (2020, January 21). Eco et franc CFA : quatre mariages et un enterrement. Retrieved January 29, 2020, from www.jeuneafrique.com: https://www.jeuneafrique.com/884260/economie/tribune-eco-et-franc-cfa-quatre-mariages-et-un-enterrement/
Nubukpo, K., & Deh, C. P. (2016). L’envol de l’épervier : le défi de l’émergence Togolaise. Lomé: Graines de Pensées.
Nubukpo, K., Belinga, M., & Dembélé, D. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la sevitude monétaire. Paris, France: La dispute.
Nubupko, K., Belinga, M. Z., Tinel, B., & Dembélé, D. M. (2016). Sortir l’Afrique de la servitude monétaire : A qui profite le franc CFA ? Paris: La Dispute.
Oatley, T., & Kindred, W. (2014). Handbook of the international political economy of monetary relations. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.
O’Brien, R., & Williams, M. (2013). Global political economy. Palgrave Macmillan.
Ould-Ahmed, P. (1999). Politiques monétaires, comportements bancaires et crises de financement en Russie : les vicissitudes des années 1990. Revue d’études comparatives Est-Ouest,, 30(2-3), 89-121.
Pape, L. D. (1998). L’impact des taux directeurs de la BCEAO sur les taux débiteurs des banques . Notes d’Information et Statistiques, 483-484.
Pigeaud, F. (2016). Une monnaie nocive pour les Etats africains. Médiapart.
Polzer, T. (2001). Corruption : Deconstructing the World Bank Discourse. Development Studies Institute, London School of Economics, Working Paper Series, 1470(2320).
Profant, T. (2010). French Geopolitics in Africa : From Neo-colonialism to Identity. Perspectives, 18(1).
Saint-Légier, R. (1956). La zone franc, mécanismes, problèmes internationaux. Annuaire francaise de droit international, 2(1956), 260-27.
Shatz, H. J., & Tarr, D. (2000). Exchange Rate Overvaluation and Trade Protection : Lessons from Experience . The World Bank.
Shillington, K. (2005). History of Africa. Macmillian Publishers Limited.
Smith, N. (2013). What is ”neoclassical” economics?
Strange, S. (1988). States and markets. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Todaro, M., & Smith, S. (2015). Economic development. Harlow: Pearson.
Trésor Direction Générale. (2013). 40 ans d’histoire de la Zone franc – Principes et modalités de fonctionnement de la coopération monétaire. Paris: Ministère de l’économie, République Francaise .
UEMOA. (1973). Traité du 14 novembre 1973 constituant l’Union Monétaire Ouest Africaine. Préambule.
United Nations. (2006). Human Development Report. Beyond scarcity: Power, poverty and the global water crisis. United Nations Development Programme. Palgrave Macmillan.
United Nations Development Programme. (1997). Human Development Report . Oxford University Press.
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983, August). Credit policy, inflation and growth in a financially repressed economy. Journal of Development Economics,(13).
van Wijnbergen, S. (1983). Interest rate management in LDC. Journal of Monetary Economics, 12(12).
World Bank. (2017). GDP per capita growth (annual%). The World Bank Group.
